Features of peer mentoring program elements for university professors: Synthesis based on Roberts model
Subject Areas :nasrin ozaei 1 , alireza assareh 2 , mahmood mehrmohamadi 3 , mohamadreza emamjomeh 4 , gholamali ahmadi 5
1 - rajaei university
2 - Faculty member of Rajai University
3 - Faculty member of Tarbiat Modares University
4 - Faculty member of Tarbiat Dabir Shahid Rajaei University
5 - Faculty member of Tarbiat Dabir Rajaei University
Keywords: mentoring, peer mentoring, professors, university,
Abstract :
Abstract Peer mentoring is one of the new approaches in the professional development of employees, especially university professors. The purpose of this study is to investigate the elements of peer mentoring program for university professors, qualitative research approach and its method of synthesis research based on Roberts (2007) model. The research population consists of 347 articles on the features and models of peer mentoring for teaching professors and instructors that have been presented in prestigious scientific journals from 2005 to 2021. The research sample includes 58 scientific research articles that have been purposefully collected. Research data were collected from qualitative analysis of the studied documents. Based on the data analysis, peer mentoring components were classified into 5 dimensions and 29 factors. These dimensions include individual dimension (including factors; job skills, leadership skills, balance, decision-making skills, problem-solving skills, perceptual skills, accessibility, personality dimensions, motivation), organizational dimension (including On factors: professional development, support and encouragement, infrastructure, attention to professional components, organizational and managerial structure), cultural dimension (including factors; attention to cultural requirements) and dimension of requirements and musts (including On factors: dignity, pedagogical knowledge management, clear strategy, process personalization, cost-effectiveness, security, based on the principles of the workplace curriculum, based on hiatology, program requirements and role-paying) and communications (including component Such as, positive communication, social communication, communication in relationships and usefulness). Therefore, in order to better implement peer mentoring patterns, it is better to pay attention to all these 5 dimensions.
Karimian, Zahra and Abolghasemi, Mahmoud. (1391). Education and maturity of faculty members in medical universities, a look at the past, a vision for tomorrow, Journal of Higher Education, 5 (17), pp. 76-49.
2.Mehr Mohammadi, Mahmoud (2016). The Road to Farhangian University, Teacher Development, Volume 35, Number
3.Zare Sifat, Sadegh; Dehghani, Marzieh; Hakimzadeh, Rezvan; Karami, Morteza; Salehi, Keyvan (1397). Missed Curricula Professional Development of Faculty Members of Iranian Universities: Ferdowsi University of Mashhad., Quarterly Journal of Education Curriculum Studies, 9 (17), pp. 183-216.
4. Kegan, R. (1994). In over our heads: The mental demands of modern life. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
5. Ernstein, Allen C. and Hankins, Francis P. (2005) Principles, Principles, and Curriculum Issues (Vol. I) (Holy Humiliation, translator).
6. Renard, Laurent (2005). Executive Coaching for professional organizations, PHD thesis, school of humanities, The American university of London.
7. Philips, K.R. (1998) the Achilles. Heel of coaching, Training & Development, Vol. 52, Issue 3, pp. 41-44.
8. Cannon, M. M. (2014). An exploration of formal mentoring experiences of junior faculty in associate degree nursing programs. Ph.D. Dissertation in Education, University of Alabama.
9. Sufi, Farzaneh, Yassini, Ali and Shiri, Ardeshir (2015). An analysis of the nature, dimensions and experiences of mentoring in schools: linking opinion and practice. Fifth International Conference on Management and Accounting and 2nd Conference on Entrepreneurship and Open Innovation. P: 1-14.a Tehran .
10. Bland, C. J., & Schmitz, C. C. (1986). Characteristics of the successful researcher and implications for faculty development. Journal of Medical Education, 61(1), 22–31.
11. Byrne, M. W., & Keefe, M. R. (2002). Building research competence in nursing through mentoring. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 34(4), 391–396.
12. Zeind, C. S., Zdanowicz, M., MacDonald, K., & Parkhurst, C. (2005). Developing a sustainable faculty mentoring program. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, 69(1-5), K1.
13. Bower GG. (2007). Mentoring 1st year faculty in physical education departments: Enhancing the academic experience. Indiana Health, Physical Education, Recreation, & Dance Journal, 36 (2), 15-8.
14. Taylor CT, Berry TM. (2008). A pharmacy faculty academy to foster professional growth and long-term retention of junior faculty members. American journal of pharmaceutical education, 72(2), 2.
15. Falzaran, M. (2011). Describing the Occurrence and Influence of Mentoring for Occupational Therapy Faculty Members Who are on the Tenure Track or Eligible foe Reappointment, Ph.D. Dissertation in Philosophy in Health Sciences, Seton Hall University.
16. Riegle, S. G. (2004). Senior female faculty and mentoring practices. Ph.D. Dissertation in Science, University of Michigan
17. Cook, M. (2011). Mentoring New Faculty at a Christian University in the Northeast: Developing a Framework for Programming, Ph.D. Dissertation in Education, Johnson & Wales University .
18. Zellers, D. F., Howard, V. M., & Barcic, M. A. (2008). Faculty Mentoring Programs: Reenvisioning Rather Than Reinventing the Wheel. Review of Educational Research, 78(3), 552-588.
19. Anafarta, A., & Apaydin, C. (2016). The Effect of Faculty Mentoring on Career Success and Career Satisfaction. International Education Studies, 9(6), 22.
20. Mirbagher Ajrpez, Neda, Zaghari Tafreshi, Mansoureh, Mohtashami, Jamileh and Zayeri, Farid (2016) Mentoring in operating room students education: a systematic review. Journal of Nursing Education, (3): 47-53
21. Sorcinelli, M.D. & Yun, J. (2007). From mentor to mentoring networks: Mentoring in the new academy, Change, 39(6), pp. 58-60.
22. Ambrose, L. (2003). Multiple mentoring: Discover alternatives to a one-on-one learning relationship. Healthcare Executive, 18(4), 58–60.
23. Packard, B. W.-L., Walsh, L., & Seidenberg, S. (2004). Will that be one mentor or two? A cross-sectional study of women’s mentoring during college. Mentoring and Tutoring, 12(1), 71–85.
24. Beane-Katner, L. (2014). Anchoring a mentoring network in a new faculty development program. Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning, 22(2), 91–103.
25. Akinla,Olawunmi., Hagan, Pamela and William Atiomo. (2018). A systematic review of the literature describing the outcomes of near-peer mentoring programs for first year medical students. BMC Medical Education 18:98
26. Buch, K., Huet, Y., Rorrer, A., & Roberson, L. (2011). Removing the barriers to full professor: A mentoring program for associate professors. The Magazine for Higher Learning, 43(6), 38–45.
27. Crawford. C.J.(2010).Managers Guide to Mentoring.Mc Graw-Hill,United States
28. Kleist And Gillman Debra. (2006).The Power of Peer Mentoring: Wisconsin Council on Developmental Disabilities, using federalfunds under P.L. 106-402.
29. Pamela S. Lottero-Perdue ,Steve Fifield(2007) A Conceptual Fram work For Higher Education Faculty Mentoring . possible by Grant Number 2 P20 RR016472-06, under the INBRE program of the National Center for Research Resources, acomponent of the National Institutes of Health (NIH).
30. Hill, Ros and Reddy ,Peter .(2007). Undergraduate peer mentoring: an investigation into processes, activities and outcomes. Psychology Learning and Teaching 6(2), 98-103.
31. Heirdsfield , Ann M. Kerryann Walsh Sue Walker, and Lynn Wilss.(2008). Peer mentoring for first-year teacher education students: the mentors’ experience: Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning, Vol. 16, No. 2, 109–124
32. Kathleen T. Heinrich . Oberleitner, Melinda G.(2012). How A Faculty Groups Peer Mentoring Of Each Others Scholarship Can Enhance Retention And Recruitment. Journal of Professional Nursing, Vol 28, No,pp 5–12 5.
33. Beltman, S., & Schaeben, M. (2012). Institution-wide peer mentoring: Benefits for mentors. The International Journal of the First Year in Higher Education, 3(2). 33-44.
34. Preez, Ronel Du,. Steenkamp ,Leon P., Stellenbosch, Roelof S. Baard.(2013). An Investigation Into A Peer Module Mentoring Programme In Economic And Management Sciences. International Business & Economics Research Journal –Volume 12, Number 10.
35. Webb , Alicia K. Tenzin Wangmo , Heidi H. Ewen , Pamela B. Teaster & Laurie R. Hatch (2014) Peer and Faculty Mentoring for Students Pursuing a PHD in Gerontology, Educational Gerontology, 35:12, 1089-1106.
36. Engler ,Andrea Colby .(2015). Understanding How Peer Mentors Make Meaning Of Their Role. Accepted by the Graduate Faculty, Indiana University, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Education.
37. Vaughan, N., Clampitt, K., & Park, N. (2016). To teach is to learn twice: The power of peer mentoring. Teaching & Learning Inquiry, 4(2).
38. Skaniakos. T ., Piirainen . A. ( 2019). The meaning of peer group mentoring in the university context. International Journal of Evidence Based Coaching and Mentoring, Vol. 17(1), pp.19-33. DOI: 10.24384/EKNZ-S730
39. Cooper, H., & Hedges, L. V. (2009). Research Synthesis as a scientific process. In H. Cooper, L. V. Hedges, and J. C. Valentine (eds.), The Handbook of Research synthesis and meta-Analysis (pp. 3-16). US: Russell Sage.
40.Prashar, A. (2015). Assessing the flipped classroom in operations management: A pilot study. Journal of Education for Business, 90(3), 126-38.
41.Moffet, J. (2015). Twelve tips for “flipping” the classroom. Medical Teacher, 37(4), 331-336.
42. Marquardt, Michael J & Loan, Peter. (2006). The Manager as mentor. Westport, Conn.:Praeger, c 2006.
43. Aladejana, Anthony ., Aladejana, Francisca., Ehindero.(2006). An Analysis of Mentoring Relationships Among Teachers: A Case Study of Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria. International Journal of Evidence Based Coaching and Mentoring Vol. 4, No.1, Spring 2006 Page 20.
44. Noonan, Mary Jo., Ballinger, Ruth ., and Rhonda Black(2007). Peer and Faculty Mentoring in Doctoral Education: International Journal of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education , Volume 19, Number 3, 251-262
45. Lennox Terrion, Jenepher ., Philion, Ruth., Dominique Leonard(2007). An Evaluation of a University Peer-Mentoring Training Programme. International Journal of Evidence Based Coaching and Mentoring Vol. 5, No.1, Page 42.
46. Moss, Jay., Teshima, John Leszcz, ., Molyn.(2008). Peer Group Mentoring of Junior Faculty: Academic Psychiatry, 32:3..
47. Alicia K. Webb , Tenzin Wangmo , Heidi H. Ewen , Pamela B. Teaster & Laurie R. Hatch. (2009). Peer and Faculty Mentoring for Students Pursuing a PHD in Gerontology, Educational Gerontology, 35:12, 1089-1106.
48.Kimberly S. Johnson., Hastings ,Nicole .,Purser ,Jama L.(2011). The Junior Faculty Laboratory: An Innovative Model of Peer Mentoring. Acad Med:86(12): 1577–1582.
49. Goff, Lori (2011) "Evaluating the Outcomes of a Peer-Mentoring Program for Students Transitioning to Postsecondary Education, "The Canadian Journal for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning: Vol. 2.
50. Huizing ,Russell L. (2012) Mentoring Together: A Literature Review of Group Mentoring, Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning, 20:1, 27-55.
51. Chester, Andrea . Burton, Lorelle Xenos, J. Sophie and Karen Elgar1(2013). Peer mentoring: Supporting successful transition for first year undergraduate psychology students: Australian Journal of Psychology 2013; 65: 30–37.
52. Scott P. Kissau , King. E. Tosky (2014). Peer Mentoring Second LanguageTeachers: A Mutually Beneficial Experience? Foreign Language Annals, Vol. xxx, Iss. xxx, pp. 1–18. © 2014 by American Council on the Teaching of Foreign Languages. DOI: 10.1111/flan.12121.
53. Jackevicius, Cynthia A. Jennifer Le, d,e,f Lama Nazer, Karl Hess, Jeffrey Wang, and Anandi V. Law(2014). A Formal Mentorship Program for Faculty Development: American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, 78 (5) Article 100.
54. Singh Satendra., Singh, Navjeevan, Upreet Dhaliwal(2014). Near-peer mentoring to complement faculty mentoring of first-year medical students in India. Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions, 11: 12
55. Christie, Hazel (2014) Peer mentoring in higher education: issues of power and control, Teaching in Higher Education, 19:8, 955-965.
56. Cynthia Jackevicius, BScPhm, PharmD, MSc, BCPS, A Formal Mentorship Program for Faculty Development , Submitted December 31, 2014; accepted April 6, 2014; published June 17, 2014.
57. Leidenfrost Birgit ,Barbara Strassnig ,Marlene Schütz ,Claus-Christian Carbon, Alfred Schabmann(2014). The Impact of Peer Mentoring on Mentee Academic Performance: Is Any Mentoring Style Better than No Mentoring at All? ternational Journal of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education 2014, Volume 26, Number 1, 102-111.
58. Nisbet, G., and McAllister, L. (2015) ‘A Critical Review of Outcomes of Peer Group Mentoring and Elements Influencing its Success and Application to Student Placement Supervisors’. International Journal of Practice-based Learning in Health and Social Care, 3 (2), 61-76.
59.Thomas ,Nicole. Bystydzienski ,Jill., Desai, Anand. (2015). Changing Institutional Culture through Peer Mentoring of Women STEM Faculty. Innov High Educ 40:143–157 .
60. Bryant Ashley Leak., Brody Abraham Aizer., Perez Adriana., Shillam, Casey , Edelman Linda S., Bond Stewart M. Foster, AOCN6 ,Victoria , & Elena O. Siegel.(2015). Development and Implementation of a Peer Mentoring Program for Early Career Gerontological Faculty. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 2015; 47:3, 258–266.
61. N´u˜ nez , Anne-Marie., Murakami, Elizabeth T. Gonzales, Leslie D. (2015). Weaving Authenticity and Legitimacy: Latina Faculty Peer Mentoring: New Directions For Higher Education , no. 171
62. Murakami ,Elizabeth T ., Núñez ,Anne-Marie.(2015). Latina Faculty Transcending Barriers: Peer Mentoring in a Hispanic-serving Institution. Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning, Vol. 22, No. 4, 284–301.
63. Polol, Linda H., Evans,Arthur T. (2015). Group Peer Mentoring: An Answer to the Faculty Mentoring Problem? A Successful Program at a Large Academic Department of Medicine. Journal Of Continuing Education In The Health Professiong, 35(3):192–200.
64. Rieske,Laura. Benjamin,Jo Mimi (2015). Utilizing Peer Mentor Roles in Learning Communities: New Directions For Student Services, no. 149.
65. Harvey , Marina., Ambler,Trudy Ambler & Jayde Cahir .(2015) .Spectrum pproach to Mentoring: an evidence-based approach to mentoring for academics working in higher education, Teacher Development, 21:1, 160-174.
66.Yusta-Loyoa, José María., Cepero-Ascasob, María Dolores., Prieto-Martínc, José ., Abadía-Valled, Ana Rosa., Bueno-Garcíad ,Concepción(2015). Peer mentoring at the university level: the importance of organization: International Conference on University Teaching and Innovation, 2-4.
67. Waddell, Janice., Martin ,Jennifer., Schwind ,Jasna K., and Jennifer L. Lapum. (2016). A Faculty-Based Mentorship Circle:Positioning New Faculty for Success: Canadian Journal of Higher Education Revue canadienne d’enseignement supérieur Volume 46, No. 4, pages 60 – 75.
68. Wong,Carissa, Stake-Doucet ,Natalie, Lombardo, Celia, Sanzone,Lia and Argerie Tsimicalis(2016). An Integrative Review of Peer Mentorship Programs for Undergraduate Nursing Students: Journal of Nursing Education • Vol. 55, No. 3, 2016 141
69.Wang, Sheng., Tomlinson, ., Edward C And Raymond A. Noe. (2016). The Role of Mentor Trust and Prote´ge´ Internal Locus of Control in Formal Mentoring Relationships, Journal Psychological Association, Vol. 95, No. 2, 358–367.
70. Mills, Joanna. Barakat , Shima and Shailendra Vyakarnam(2016). Impact of mentoring and peer-learning within a global entrepreneurship programme: See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303766477
71. Booth, S., Merga, M., & Mat Roni, S. (2016). Peer-mentors reflect on the benefits of mentoring: An autoethog-raphy. International Journal of Doctoral Studies, 11, 383-402.
72. Webb, N., Cox, D., & Carthy, A. (2016). You've Got a Friend in Me: The Effects of Peer Mentoring on the First Year Experience for Undergraduate Students. Paper presented at the Higher Education in Transformation Symposium, Oshawa, Ontario, Canada. Retrieved from [hyperlink].
73. Sawatsky, Adam P ., Parekh ,Natasha., Muula ,Adamson S., , Mbata, Ihunanya & Thuy Bui. (2016). Cultural implications of mentoring in sub-Saharan Africa: A qualitative study: Medical Education 2016: 50: 657–669 .doi:10.1111/medu.12999.
74. Ryan, Cathryn T. Kramer, Jessica M. and Ellen S. Cohn. (2016). Exploring the Self-Disclosure Process in Peer Mentoring Relationships for Transition-Age Youth With Developmental Disabilities. Intellectual And Developmental Disabilities, Vol. 54, No. 4, 245–259 .DOI: 10.1352/1934-9556-54.4.245.
75. Lapiner ,Clara., Lassiter, Shana L., Brooks ,Adina Berrios .(2016).Guide to Best Practices in Faculty Mentoring: ColumbiaUniversity Medical Center and the Office of the Provost.
76. Collier, Peter J.(2017). Why peer mentoring is an effective approach for promoting college student success. Metropolitan Universities Vol. 28 No. 3 .
77.Matti, Pennanen., Hannu L. T. Heikkinen & Päivi Tynjälä .(2018): Virtues of Mentors and Mentees in the Finnish Model of Teachers’ Peer-group Mentoring, Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research.
78. Eret E., Yerin Güneri O., & Çapa Aydın Y. (2018). Evaluation of peer mentoring program in higher education: Does it support smooth transition of new faculty to theacademia?Journal of Higher Education and Science/Yükseköğretim ve Bilim Dergisi, 8(3), 532-541.
79. Sucuoğlu Hale (2018). Design and Implementation of Mentoring Programs, See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/326393025,DOI: 10.4018/978-1-5225-4050-2.ch017.
80. .Lowery, K., Geesa, R., & McConnell, K. (2018). Designing a peer-mentoring program for education doctorate (EdD) students: A literature review. Higher Learning Research Communications, 8(1).
81. Clarke-Midura, Jody.,Poole, Frederick., Pantic, Katarina., Hamilton, Megan., Sun, Chongning & Vicki Allan. (2018). How Near Peer Mentoring Affects Middle School Mentees: SIGCSE’18, February 21-24, Baltimore, MD, USA 665.
82. Geesa, R. L., Lowery, K., & McConnell, K. (2018). Mentee perspectives of a first-year peer mentoring program for education doctoral (EdD) students. International Journal of Doctoral Studies, 13, 471-495.
83. McConnell, Kat . Geesa, Rachel Louise . Lowery, Kendra .(2019) "Self-reflective mentoring: perspectives of peer mentors in an education doctoral program", International Journal of Mentoring and Coaching in Education
84. Swart,Arthur J. Coughlan ,Lisa-Mari & Nicole Joannou. (2019). Student perspectives of a peer mentorship programme introduced at a university of technology in South Africa: Global Journal of Engineering Education. Volume 21, Number 3,
85. Sabeghi,Hakimeh.,Vagharseyyedin, Seyyed Abolfazl And Maryam Salmni Mood(2020). Collaborative Mentoring: Perceptions of a sample of Iranian Nursingand Midwifery faculties: Journal of Advances in Medical Education & Professionalism. October 2020; Vol 8 No 4
86. Gupta,Ankur .(2020). Mentoring Faculty for Quality Enhancementin Indian Higher Education: Model Institute of Engineering and Technology, Jammu, India.
87. Stelter, Rebecca L., Kupersmidt, Janis B. and Kathryn N. Stump(2020). Establishing effective STEM mentoring relationships through mentor training. nnovation .Research & Training, 5316 Highgate Drive Suite 125, Durham,NC 27713.
88. Kram, K. E., & Isabella, L. A. (1985). Mentoring alternatives: The role of peer relationships incareer development. Academy of Management Journal, 28 (1), 110–132.
89. Mumford, A. (1993). How managers can develop managers . Hampshire, UK: Gower Publishing.Nguyen, T. M. H., & Luong, Q. T. (2008). A case study of a TESOL practicum in Vietnam: Voices from student teachers. Paper presented at the International Conference: Rethinking English
90. Kurtts, S. A., & Levin, B. B. (2000). Using peer coaching with preservice teachers to develop refl ective practice and collegial support. Teacher Education, 11 (3), 297–310.
91. Walsh, K., Elmslie, L., & Tayler, C. (2002). Pairs on practicum (trial): Early childhood students collaborate with peers in preschool/kindergarten. Paper presented at the Australian Association for Research in Education (AARE) Conference, Brisbane.
92. Hobson, A. J., Ashby, P., Malderez, A., & Tomlinson, P. D. (2009). Mentoring beginning teachers: What we know and what we don’t. Teaching and Teacher Education, 25(1): 207-216.
93. Masters, K. (2015). The Use of Expert Mentoring as an Adjunct to Healthcare Quality Improvement Training. Newborn and Infant Nursing Reviews, 15(2), 61-63.
94. Kim, S. S., Im, J., & Hwang, J. (2015). The effects of mentoring on role stress, job attitude, and turnover intention in the hotel industry. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 48, 68-82
95. Sandner, M. (2015). The effects of high-quality student mentoring. Economics Letters, 136, 227-232.
96. Sambunjak, D., Straus, S. E., & Marusic, A. (2011). A systematic review of qualitative research on the meaning and characteristics of mentoring in academic medicine. Journal of general internal medicine, 25(1), 72-78.
97.Angelique, H., Kyle, K., & Taylor, E. (2002). Mentors and muses: New strategies for academic success. Innovative Higher Education, 6(3), 195–209.
