List of Articles Meta-analysis

• Open Access Article
  • Abstract Page
  • Full-Text
  
  1 - An Approach in Criticism and Analysis of Islamic Revolution Novels Focusing on Criticizing Novels by Reza Amir Khani
  fateme shekardast fateme kouppa mostafa gorji محمدرضا  سنگری
  The study is a meta-analysis and a special current to arrive at the quality of presence in Persian Fictional Literature i.e. “Islamic Revolution Literature”. This meta-analysis has a functionalist direction that in triangle of bibliography, movement-graphy, and patholog More

  The study is a meta-analysis and a special current to arrive at the quality of presence in Persian Fictional Literature i.e. “Islamic Revolution Literature”. This meta-analysis has a functionalist direction that in triangle of bibliography, movement-graphy, and pathology seeks to arrive at an analytic method in reviewing criticisms to access the universal perspective in domain of criticism which explains the rate of presence in a special literary current in the environment of Iran Fiction Literature. Moreover, the meta-analysis can be effective in correct identifying of criticism, monitoring its weaknesses and fortes and introducing the gaps and harms of criticism. The under review sample in this meta-analysis contain the novels of “Reza Amir Khani” as one of the most famous author of Islamic Revolution Literary Current and assesses the function of these novels through the quality and quantity perspective of critics. Introduction defines Islamic Revolution Literature, its criticism and functions and the indicatives of the criticism of the criticism. Then the author and novels are introduced and their critics (in form of research article, promotive article, special article, descriptive article and hobby article) are reviewed and analyzed; then these analyses are meta-analyzed from different perspectives and finally stated in form of tables and charts. Manuscript profile
• Open Access Article
  • Abstract Page
  • Full-Text
  
  2 - Designing a Model for the Realization of Economic Complexity, Based on the Meta-Analysis of Scientific Research
  Mohammad Mahdi  Ahmadian Divkoti Hassanali Aghajani meysam shirkhodaei Amir Mansour Tehranchian
  10.52547/jstpi.20749.15.59.19
  Economic growth and development are among the main goals of economic policymakers, which have led them to always look for factors that accelerate economic growth. There are different theories in this regard, each of which is one of the factors influencing economic growt More

  Economic growth and development are among the main goals of economic policymakers, which have led them to always look for factors that accelerate economic growth. There are different theories in this regard, each of which is one of the factors influencing economic growth. One of the reasons for failure in the path of economic development is lack of a model for realizing economic complexity, taking into account the experiences of other countries. This research has been carried out for the purpose of a meta-analysis of research conducted in the field of economic complexity over the past few years. The statistical population of this research is the research on the complexity of the economy between 2011 and the end of 2017. Of the 35 studies reviewed, 22 cases have been identified for proper meta-analysis. These articles have been reviewed in two sections: "Meta-analysis descriptive findings" and "Qualitative assessment of articles". Descriptive findings include the time scale, the frequency of articles, the gender of the researchers and the geographical distribution of the authors and the level of the region studied (national, regional or global). In the quality assessment section, the articles are divided into three groups based on the "Blaikie" triple indicator, why and how they are categorized and analyzed. Then, by examining all the articles studied, the factors emphasized in economic complexity were extracted and in the end, considering these factors, a proposed model is proposed to achieve the complexity of the economy, which can be a way forward for managers and policymakers in the fields Economic and industrial. Manuscript profile
• Open Access Article
  • Abstract Page
  • Full-Text
  
  3 - Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness of Interventions on test anxiety reduction
  Habib Amani دکتر رامین حبیبی کلیبر abolfazl Farid Syavash Sheykhalizadeh
  Test anxiety is one of the most prevalent problems that students encounter in their studies and affects their academic performance. Over the previous decades, researchers to reduce test anxiety have used various therapy interventions. The purpose of the present study wa More

  Test anxiety is one of the most prevalent problems that students encounter in their studies and affects their academic performance. Over the previous decades, researchers to reduce test anxiety have used various therapy interventions. The purpose of the present study was to perform a meta-analysis on the effectiveness of therapy methods in reducing test anxiety of students. The method of the present research was a meta-analysis. The research instrument was a checklist of meta-analysis The statistical population includes available research related to test anxiety between the years of 2009 to 2019, and their report was published. According to the marked entry and exit criteria for the initial research, 100 effect sizes of 75 research were obtained which remained 49 effects after sensitivity analysis. The results showed that behavioral (ES=-1/858), cognitive (ES=-1/860); metacognitive (ES=-1/784) and cognitive-behavioral (ES=-1/985) methods are effective in reducing test anxiety. In addition, Interventions were more effective in reducing test anxiety in girls (ES=-1/952) and collage-students (ES=-2/096). The results of this study can guide researchers and therapists in the field of test anxiety. The results of this study show that effectiveness therapy interventions are in reducing test anxiety but cognitive-behavioral intervention was found to be more effective than other interventions. In addition, Interven-tions had a significant impact on college students. These results can guide researchers and therapists in the field of anxiety test. Manuscript profile
• Open Access Article
  • Abstract Page
  • Full-Text
  
  4 - Metatheorizing Regional Tourism: A Meta-analysis Report
  Abbasgholi Sangi Noorpour
  10.52547/journalitor.35697.10.20.249
  Considering the growing number of research articles published on regional planning and tourism worldwide, and the fact that it appears impossible for the researchers to review all of them in detail, it is necessary to analyze the studies conducted in this field whatsoev More

  Considering the growing number of research articles published on regional planning and tourism worldwide, and the fact that it appears impossible for the researchers to review all of them in detail, it is necessary to analyze the studies conducted in this field whatsoever. Moreover, as meta-analysis has recently been welcomed by Iranian researchers, it seems that in a near future, a considerable number of studies on urban and regional planning would apply meta-analysis as their research method. Therefore, this study sought to examine, based on the PRISMA statement, the reports of meta-analysis studies on regional planning published in both Iranian and Non-Iranian journals. To this end, all Iranian and Non-Iranian journals (in Persian and English) in the field of regional planning indexed during the last decade with the subject of regional tourism by such databases as Magiran, SID (Scientific Information Database, affiliated with the Academic Center for Education Culture and Research), Google Scholar, and IranDoc (Iranian Research Institute for Information Science and Technology) were examined, using meta-analysis and tourism as keywords for searching through the aforementioned databases, resulting in the identification of 38 relevant articles. Then, 13 articles were selected based on predetermined criteria, whose data were analyzed based on the PRISMA statement using descriptive statistics. The study’s findings indicated the examined meta-analysis articles were acceptably compatible with the criteria set by the PRISMA statement in terms of overall quality. Moreover, it was found that 38% percent of the articles lacked expected methodological quality. Also, the quality of the meta-analysis studies reported in the field of regional tourism was found to be moderate. Manuscript profile
• Open Access Article
  • Abstract Page
  • Full-Text
  
  5 - Determining the competencies of Human Resource with the Approach of marketing educational services (a meta-Analysis literature review)
  Saeed Talebi seyyed mahmoud  shabgoo monsef Kambiz Shahroodi فرزین فرحبد
  High quality education is a prerequisite for a flourishing economy of a country. The quality of education can be improved by considering new approaches. On the other hand, the characteristics and competencies of specialists in the field of education and focusing on comp More

  High quality education is a prerequisite for a flourishing economy of a country. The quality of education can be improved by considering new approaches. On the other hand, the characteristics and competencies of specialists in the field of education and focusing on competency-based human resources in this field is another approach that will have a direct relationship with the quality of education and improving competition in this market. Therefore, the research object is to explain the key competencies of human resources in the field of education services with the approach of marketing education services. In this study, the results of the resources of necessary competencies in educational services during the years (2020-205) & (1399-1385) are analyzed by a meta-analyzed method and components of educational services marketing competency were counted. From 91 primary sources, 67 sources were selected based on abstract, then 39 ones were selected based on the content, and finally 12 sources were considered as relevant sources. Heterogeneity of the effect size was confirmed and then the effect of each index was studied using CMA software. By the results of the Q test, the studies are heterogeneous with 99% confidence, the use of combining results of the random effects model was confirmed. According to the random results in software analysis, 24 key competencies were found in the field of educational services marketing. The findings indicated that the competencies "time management" and "creativity and innovation" have the highest effect sizes of 0.584 and 0.538 respectively, and the competencies of "listening skills" and "power of analysis" with a value of 0.285 have the lowest effect sizes among the competencies. Manuscript profile
• Open Access Article
  • Abstract Page
  • Full-Text
  
  6 - Spiritual health in Iranian nurses: a meta-analysis
  پروانه  اصفهانی Mohammad Ali  Khammer
  Introduction & Objective: Spiritual health is one of the important dimensions of human health and an important approach in promoting public health. Therefore, the present study was conducted to determine the level of spiritual health in Iranian nurses. Methods: This st More

  Introduction & Objective: Spiritual health is one of the important dimensions of human health and an important approach in promoting public health. Therefore, the present study was conducted to determine the level of spiritual health in Iranian nurses. Methods: This study was performed by meta-analysis. All related studies of nurses' spiritual health were searched in the PubMed, Web of Science, Scopus, Magiran, and SID databases and the Google Scholar search engine by the end of 22July 2021 with the appropriate keywords. In this study, the heterogeneity of studies was evaluated using index I2 and the probability of diffusion in diffusion by Egger test and Meta regression model to evaluate the variables suspected of heterogeneity at a significance level of 0.05. 16 articles were analyzed using Comprehensive Meta-Analysis software. Results: Based on a random model, the rate of spiritual health in Iranian nurses was 82.53 ± 2.81 (77.02-88.04: 95% confidence interval). The mean and standard deviation of religious and existential health were 37.60± 7.30 and 37.38±7.75, respectively. There was a significant relationship between sample size, year, mean age and spiritual health (P <0.05). Conclusion: According to the research findings, the level of spiritual health was optimal. Therefore, given the country's adherence to moral values, achieving such a result is not unexpected. Manuscript profile
• Open Access Article
  • Abstract Page
  • Full-Text
  
  7 - Elements and Advantages of Gamification Method in Education: A Meta-Analysis
  Reza tohand Mehrangiz alinejad Badr al-Sadat daneshmand
  Gamification has emerged as one of the novel educational methods that aims to improve education by creating a happy, exciting, dynamic and active platform. In fact, this method strengthens different learning channels of learners. Gamification of educational content offe More

  Gamification has emerged as one of the novel educational methods that aims to improve education by creating a happy, exciting, dynamic and active platform. In fact, this method strengthens different learning channels of learners. Gamification of educational content offers the concepts and contents in a more convenient way. In this regard, this research was conducted with the aim of exploring the elements and advantages of the gamification method using the meta-analysis approach. The study corpus included national and international studies conducted in the field of gamification, initially 79 national studies and 301 international studies were identified and downloaded, and among them the most relevant sources were selected as the statistical sample, including 30 national studies and 65 international studies (total 95 studies). These sources (articles, dissertations and treatises) were searched in national scientific data bases such as magiran, sid, noormagz, irandoc, ricest as well as comprehensive humanities portal and international scientific data bases such as Proquest, Springer, Sciencedirect, Mdpi, Researchgate, Ieee, Acm, and Google scholars. Next the corpus was analyzed with the aim of identifying the most significant and widely applied elements of the gamification approach and the advantages of this approach. It should be mentioned that the articles presented in the conference were excluded from the study corpus. According to the findings of the research, score, reward, challenge, feedback, leveling, story, interaction and competition with the highest percentage of frequency were the most important and practical elements of gamification in education. Also, creating and promoting interaction and participation, creating motivation, providing a platform for deep learning, improving performance, creating attractiveness and increasing it, developing cognitive growth, creating excitement and vitality, increasing the effectiveness of education, creating a platform for the use of educational technologies, developing social growth, development of soft skills and reduction of disorder were among the benefits of gamification in researches, among these things, creating and promoting interaction and participation, providing a platform for deep learning, creating motivation, improving performance, developing cognitive development, creating excitement and vitality, increasing Effectiveness of education, creation of a platform for the use of educational technologies had the highest frequency percentage. Manuscript profile
• Open Access Article
  • Abstract Page
  • Full-Text
  
  8 - Meta-analysis of studies conducted in the field of smart city indicators in Iran
  Mohammad javad  samani nezhad neda khodakaramiangilan
  The process of urbanization in the world and the problems arising from it bring great challenges to cities, and the concept of a smart city has been created as a solution to the problems of cities. Therefore, prioritizing criteria and indicators is of particular importa More

  The process of urbanization in the world and the problems arising from it bring great challenges to cities, and the concept of a smart city has been created as a solution to the problems of cities. Therefore, prioritizing criteria and indicators is of particular importance. The aim of the present study was to investigate the indicators affecting the smart city in Iran. The present study is a descriptive-analytical research in which the meta-analysis method was used. The statistical population of the research includes all the researches conducted in the field of smart city indicators that were published in Normagz, Jihad University, Humanities, Mogiran and Irandak databases from 1396 to 1400. In this research, the amount of collaboration and participation of researchers, statistical society, sampling method and time pattern of publication of articles and variables used and their effect size in smart city studies in Iran were investigated. The results showed that the level of cooperation and teamwork of researchers in research is acceptable and most of the research was done in the period of 1399 to 1400. Also, the results showed that most of the researchers were researching in a specific field. Finally, the results of the effect size showed that the smart economy has the largest effect size in the smart city, and smart people are the second most important variable in the smart city. Smart government and smart environment are also the next variables. Manuscript profile
• Open Access Article
  • Abstract Page
  • Full-Text
  
  9 - Meta-analysis of studies conducted in the field of smart city indicators in Iran
  Mohammad javad  samani nezhad neda khodakaramiangilan
  Mohammad Javad Samaninezhad Neda Khodakarmian Gilan Abstract The process of urbanization in the world and the problems arising from it bring great challenges to cities, and the concept of a smart city has been created as a solution to the problems of cities. More

  Mohammad Javad Samaninezhad Neda Khodakarmian Gilan Abstract The process of urbanization in the world and the problems arising from it bring great challenges to cities, and the concept of a smart city has been created as a solution to the problems of cities. Smart cities are defined as cities that pay attention to human capital, social and communication infrastructure, will improve the economy and quality of life, wise management of natural resources and cooperative governance. Now, it should be noted that smart building should be on the agenda in cities and the construction of a new city should be combined with new ideas. Therefore, prioritizing criteria and indicators is of particular importance. The aim of the current research is to investigate the indicators affecting the smart city in Iran. The present study is a descriptive-analytical research in which the meta-analysis method was used. The statistical population of the research includes all the researches conducted in the field of smart city indicators that were published in Normagz, Jihad University, Humanities, Mogiran and Irandak databases from 1396 to 1400. In this research, the amount of cooperation and participation of researchers, statistical community, sampling method and time pattern of publication of articles and variables used and their effect size in smart city studies in Iran have been investigated. The results showed that the level of cooperation and teamwork of researchers in research is acceptable and most of the research was done in the period of 1399 to 1400. Also, most of these researches were in the field of specific fields. Finally, the results of the effect size showed that the smart economy has the largest effect size in the smart city, and smart people are the second most important variable in the smart city, on the other hand, smart government and smart environment are the next variables. Manuscript profile