Obligations of the Adopter Couples towards the Adopted Child and the Enforcement of it in the Iranian Legal System with a Comparative Study in English Law
Subject Areas : child rights
1 - Master of Private Law, Department of Law and Political Science, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
Keywords: Child Adoption, Guardianship Obligations, Enforcement, Iranian Law, British Law ,
Abstract :
Child Adoption is an effective entity in terms of improving the living standards of homeless and abused children and couples or people without children, as well as in terms of positive social reflections. In this regard, high support of the adopted child will be necessary by regulating the obligations of guardians and enforcement of them. Obligations of guardians in Iranian law include transferring part of the property, the provision of child expenses, life insurance for the child and custody and good behavior and not to commit acts leading to disqualification, which in case of violation of each one according to the relevant rules will lead to the termination of the adoption, the change of the custody order and the compensation of the damages to the adopted child. In English law, on the other hand, there is a complete adoption system, according to which the relationship resulting from adoption is fully consistent with the legal relationship between the children and their biological parents, which reduces the distinction between the obligations of biological and non-biological guardians. But, in recent laws, a kind of incomplete adoption under the name of ‘Special Guardianship’ with specific obligations has also been identified in this country. In English law, due to the guardian's obligations, which include alimony, care and decision-making in the affairs of the adopted child, there is a guarantee of performances such as obliging and guiding the guardian to perform legal duties and the possibility of prosecution in case of child abuse. Also, according to the judicial procedure and the emphasis of the law on the principle of the material and spiritual well-being of the child, contrary to the rule, in very special and exceptional circumstances, formal adoption can be terminated.
1. Myers ED. The English Adoption Law, Social Service Review. The University of Chicago Press.1930; 4(1): 53-63.
2. Keating J. Adoption in England and Wales: The Twentieth Century. 2017. Available at: http://www.historyandpolicy.org/docs/dfe-jenny-keating.pdf.
3. Adoption and Children Act 2002. The National Archives, Available at: legislation.gov.uk.
4. Howell D. The Adoption and Children Act 2002: An Overview. 2014. Available at: http://www.courtroomadvice.co.uk/.
5. Safaei SH, Emami A. Family Law. Tehran: University of Tehran Press; 1992.
6. Emami A. Adoption in Current Iranian Law. Journal of Philosophical-Theological Research. 2000; 2(3): 38-59.
7. The Children Act 1989; Guidance and Regulations. Volume 1, Court Orders, para 2.6.
8. Gheera M, Jarrett T. Parental responsibility. House of Commons Library; 2011.
9. Children Act 1989. The National Archives. Available at: legislation.gov.uk.
10. Tafreshi M, Purseyed B. Compulsion to fulfill the same obligation (guarantee of fulfillment of defects in obligations in comparative law). Daneshvar Magazine. 2000; 7(28): 103-111.
11. Tarazi S. A Study of Adoption in Iranian, British and Swedish Law. Payam-e-Danesh Magazine. 2009; 1(38):65-76.
12. Safaei SH. Family Law. 2 ed. Tehran: University of Tehran Press; 1997.
13. Safaei SH. Proximity and genealogy and its effects. Tehran: University of Tehran Press; 1995.
14. Mousavi Bojnourdi SM, Alaei Novin F. A Study of the Adoption Situation after the Islamic Revolution. Matin Research Journal. 2009; 12(42):21-46.
15. Abedi M, Ghabuli Dorafshan S, Saeedi A. Barriers to parental liability to children. Advocate Quarterly. 2015; 1(14): 91-105.
16. Understanding Adoption. Available at: http://www.family-solicitors.co.uk/Adoption. [17 June 2016]
17. Sloan B. Post-adoption contact reform: compounding the State-ordered termination of parenthood?. The Cambridge Law Journal. 2014; 73(2): 378-404.
18. Arfa Nia B, Jurfi H. Legal status of adoption in Iranian law, international regulations and conflict of laws. Journal of Free Legal Researches. 2015; 8 (28): 1-27.
19. Julie D. Can an adoption order be undone?. Availbae at: http://www.transparencyproject.org.uk/. [17 June 2016].