Needs assessment of human resources soft skills learning and development programs in public organizations
Subject Areas :mina boustanirad 1 , سید مهدی الوانی 2 , Ali Hamidizadeh 3
1 - کاندیدای دکترا؛ مدیریت منابع انسانی؛ دانشگاه تهران؛ دانشکدگان فارابی،قم، ایران
2 - Professor, Department of Public Management, Islamic Azad University, Qazvin Branch, Qazvin, Iran
3 - Assistant Professor of Public Administration, Department of public management, Farabi Campus, University of Tehran, Qom, Iran
Keywords: .Needs assessment, learning and development, soft skills.,
Abstract :
Needs assessment is a first step in the process of human resources soft skills learning and development programs designing, and paying attention to it, will increase the effectiveness of them. this study addresses the need assessment for learning, and development programs of human resources soft skills in public organizations. Lack of attention to the essential differences between soft and hard skills in the needs assessment stage, will cause problems in the later stages of the personnel development process. Based on this, first the components of human resources soft skills were identified using the systematic review method; Then in order to identify other components of the needs assessment, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 23 experts in the field of human resources training and development, and content analysis was performed. Then, the findings validity of the content analysis, was calculated using the Delphi method, and descriptive statistics, and was confirmed by reaching the maximum consensus of the panelists participating in the study. Finally, soft skills were identified in two categories of individual, and social soft skills with 20 components, and needs assessment components with two main themes, four sub-themes and eight codes. Lack of proper attention to soft skills by public organizations indicates their need to designing these programs. It is also worthwhile to pay attention to the codification of soft skills in the jobs description in the needs assessment stage, and the necessary .classification between managerial and non-managerial jobs in terms of the type of their need for soft skills.
References:
1. Abbaszadegan SM, Torkzadeh J. (2009). surveys need training in organizations, Tehran, Press Release Joint Stock Company. 2. Abbaszadegan M, Torkzadeh G. (2000). [Need's assessment in organizations]. Tehran: Publishing Company.
3. Akdere, Mesut., Hickman, Louis., Kirchner, Michael., 2019., Developing Leadership Competencies for STEM Fields: The Case of Purdue Polytechnic Leadership Academy., Advances in Developing Human Resources, 21(3), 49-71.
4. Alam M, Gale A, Brown M, Khan AI .(2010) The importance of human skills in project management professional development. Internat. J. Managing Projects Bus. 3(3), 495-516.
5. Aminoroaya M, Yarmohammadiian MH, Ehsanpour S, Hassan zadeh A, Bahrami S. [Educational needs assessment of the staff managers in Isfahan University of Medical Sciences]. J Health Admin, 8(20):61- 7.
6. Andrew J, Higson, H. (2008). Graduate employability, ‘soft skills’ versus ‘hard’ business knowledge: A European study. Higher Education in Europe. 33(4). 411-422.
7. Armstrong Melser N. (2019). Teaching Soft Skills in a Hard World: Skills for Beginning Teachers, Rowman & Littlefield. M12.
8. Ahmed, Faheem., Fernando Capretz, Luiz., Bouktif, Salah., Campbell, Piers. (2013). Soft Skills and Software Development: A Reflection from Software Industry. International Journal of Information Processing and Management (IJIPM), 4 (3). 171-191.
9. Babić V, Slavković M. (2011). Soft and hard skills development: a current situation in serbian companies. Management, Knowledge ana Learning International Confronce. 407-411.
10. Bartel, J. (2018). Office Soft Skills. 3rd edition. https://wayzgoosepress.com.
11. Beardmore K W. (2019). Soft skills: old & new. University of Kentucky Uknowledge. Theses and Dissertations-Educational Policy Studies and Evaluation, https://uknowledge.uky.edu/epe_etds/65, A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Education, Director: Dr. Jane Jensen, College of Education, University of Kentucky.
12. Bergh AM, Van Staden CW, Joubert PM, Krüger C, Pickworth GE, Roos JL et al. (2006). Medical students perceptions of their development of ‘soft skills’ Part II : The development of ‘soft skills’ through ‘guiding and growing, Official journal of the South African Academy of Family Practice/Primary Care. 48 (8), 15.
13. Beretta R. A. (1996). critical review of the Delphi technique. Nurse Res, 3(4), 79–89.
14. Bhatnagar N, Bhatnagar M. (2012). Effective communication and soft skills, strategies for success. Dorling kindesley. Delhi, India. Blazquez M, Herrarte A, Llorente- Heras R. Competencies, occupational status, and earnings among European university graduates. Economics of Education Review. 2017; 62, 16-34.
15. BORGHANS, L., WEEL, B., WEINBERG, B. A. (2008). Interpersonal Styles and Labor Market Outcomes. Journal of Human Resources, 43 (4), 815-858.
16. Borner, K., Scrivner, O., Gallant, M., Ma, S., Liu, X., Chewning, K., Wu, L., & Evans, J. (2018). Skill discrepancies between research, education, and jobs reveal the critical need to supply soft skills for the data economy. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 115(50), 12630-12637.
17. Boyatzis, R E. (1982), The Competent Manager : A model for effective performance, Wiley, New York.
18. Brill R.T, Gilfoil D. M, Doll K. (2014). Exploring Predictability Of Instructor Ratings Using A Quantitative Tool For Evaluating Soft Skills Among MBA Students, American Journal Of Business Education- Third Quarter. 7 (3), 175- 181.
19. Braun, V. & Clarke, V. (2006). Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology, Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77-101.
20. Cherian, Jacob., Farouq, Sherine. (2013). Does Effective Leadership Style Drive Financial Performance of Banks? Analysis in the Context of UAE Banking Sector., International Journal of Economics and Finance; 5 (7), 105-114.
21. Cimatti B. (2016). Definition, development, assessment of soft skills and their role for the quality of organizations and enterprises. International Journal for Quality Research. 10(1), 97–130.
22. Cinque M. Lost in translation. (2016). Soft skills development in European countries. Tuning Journal for Higher Education. 3 (2): 389-427.
23. Clarke M. (2018). Rethinking graduate employability: The role of capital, individual attributes and context. Studies in Higher Education. 43(11), 1923-1937.
24. CPA Canada. (2012). The chartered professional accountant competency map. Understanding the competencies a candidate must demonstrate to become a CPA. Retrieved from http:// unification.cpacanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/CompetencyMap.pdf.
25. Crawford, Alleah., Weberb, Melvin R., Lee (Jay), JungHoon .(2020). "Using a grounded theory approach to understand the process ofteaching soft skills on the job so to apply it in the hospitalityclassroom", Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism Education 26,1002392, 2-7.
26. Dall’Amico, E., and Verona, S. (2015). Cross-Country Survey on Soft Skills Mostly Required by Companies to Medium/High Skilled Migrants: Methodological approach for a common framework of Soft Skills at work. Ceipiemonte S.c.p.a., for Valorize High Skills Migrant (VHSM) Project, No. 2014-1-IT02- KA204-003515. Torino, Italy.
27. Devedzic V, Tomic B, Jovanovic J, Kelly M, Milikic N, Dimitrijevic S et al. (2018). Metrics for students' soft skills. Applied Measurement in Education. 31(4), 283-296.
28. DewiyaniS M. J. (2015). Improving Students Soft Skills using Thinking Process Profile Based on Personality Types. International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education (IJERE). 4 (3), 118-129.
29. Dixon J, Belnap C, Albrecht C, Lee K (2010) The importance of soft skills. Corporate Finance Rev. 14(6):35–38.
30. Dubey RS, Tiwari V. (2020). Operationalisation of soft skill attributes and determining the existing gap in novice ICT professionals. International Journal of Information Management. 50, 375–386.
31. Fixsen, A., Ridge, D., 2019., Shades of Communitas: A Study of Soft Skills Programs, Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, 48(4), 510–537.
32. Graham HT, Bennett R. (2002), Human Resources management. London: Longman Group. 33. Ghahremani M. (2009). Organizational Learning Management Tehran, martyr Beheshti University Publications Center.
34. Ghorbanizadeh, V., Nangir, STH., (2014).,Practical guide to meta-analysis., Tehran., Sociologists Publications.
35. Gibert A, Tozer W. C, Westoby M. (2017). Teamwork, soft skills, and research training. Trends in ecology & evolution. 32(2), 81-84.
36. Grugulis, Irena., Vincent, Steven. (2009). “Whose skill is it anyway? ‘soft’ skills and polarization”, Work, employment and society, Volume 23(4), 597–615.
37. Hairi A. F B., Ahmad Toee, B. M N B, Razzaly, C.W B. (2011). Employers. perception on soft skills of graduates: a study of Intel Elite soft skill training, International Conference on Teaching & Learning in Higher Education (ICTLHE). https://www.researchgate.net/publication/279480523.
38. Hartmann, B. L., & Jahren, C. T. (2015). Leadership: Industry needs for entry-level engineering positions. Journal of STEM Education: Innovations and Research, 16(3), 13-19.
39. Hajati K, Rahmat Hidayat D, Aswad M. (2018). Development of Soft skill Training Models to Increase Personal and Social Competencies of Educators Prospective. International Journal of English Literature and Social Sciences (IJELS). 3 (6), 1253- 1257.
40. Haselberger D, Oberheumer P, Perez E, Cinque M, Capasso D. (2012). Mediating Soft Skills at Higher Education Institutions. Handbook of ModEs Project, Education and Culture DG Lifelong Learning Programme. European Union. Brussels.
41. Hillage, J., Regan, J., Dickson, J. and McLoughlin, K. (2002) Employers Skill Survey, 2002, Research Report 372. Nottingham: DfES.
42. Hillmer, G. (2007). Social and Soft Skills Training Concept in Engineering Education. International Conference on Engineering Education - ICEE 2007, September 3-7, 2007, Coimbra, Portugal.
43. Holloway, I. and Todres, L. (2003), The status of method: flexibility, consistency and coherence, Qualitative Research, 3, 345-357.
44. Holzer, H. J., Stoll, M. A., & Wissoker, D. (2004). Job performance and retention among welfare recipients. Social Service Review, 78(3), 343–369.
45. Ibrahim, Rosli., Boerhannoeddin, Ali., Kazeem Kayode, Bakare. (2017). The effect of soft skills and training methodology on employee performance, European Journal of Training and Development, 41 (4), 1-33.
46. Iyengar, R.V. (2017). People Matter: Networking and career development. The IUP Journal of Soft Skills, 11(1), 7-16.
47. Izadkhah, F., Ghaffari, M., Mohebbi, S., Gharlipour, Z., Ahmadi, Z., (2019)., Educational needs assessment of faculty members of Qom University of Medical Sciences; Journal of Qom University of Medical Sciences., 13 (9), 69-79.
48. Izadikhah, Z., Chris, J.J. and Loxton, N. (2010), “An integrative approach to personality: behavioural approach system, mastery approach orientation and environmental cues in the prediction of work performance”, Personality and Individual Differences, Vol. 48 No. 5, pp. 590-595.
49. Jain V.(2009). Importance of soft skills development in education. 2009, Retrieved July 8. 2014. from http://school of educators.com/2009/02/importance-of-soft-skills-development-in-education/.
50. Jolly S. S. (2012). Developing Soft Skills for Enhancing Employability of Engineering Graduates. International Journal of Engineeing and Management Research. 2(5), 54-56.
51. Kanokorn S, Pongtorn P, Sujanya S. (2014). Soft Skills Development to Enhance Teachers’ Competencies in Primary Schools". Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences. 112, 842 – 846.
52. Kechagias K. (2011). Teaching and assessing soft skills. 1st Second Chance School of Thessaloniki (Neapolis) Str. Strempenioti, 1st and 3rd Gymnasium 56760 Neapolis (Thessaloniki) available.
53. Keneley, M., & Jackling, B. (2011). The acquisition of generic skills of culturally-diverse student cohorts. Accounting Education, 20(6), 605–623.
54. Khaleghkhah, A., Najafi, H. (2018). Extraction of Soft Skills Components of Educational Managers by Exploratory Mixed Method (Design of a Measurement Tool), Quarterly Journal of New Approach in Educational Management, Year 9, 1 (3), 25-43.
55. Koka, Anjani Srikanth. (2016). A Critical Analysis of the Soft Skills Requirements of the IT industry and the Soft Skills Training Provided in Select Engineering Colleges of Andhra Prades, Birla Institute of Technology and Science, 225P, Birla Institute of Technology and Science.
56. Kovarik A, Warren G. (2020). Improved Soft Skills and University Club Involvement: Are They Connected?. Journal of Business. 5 (1), 01-06.
57. Kranz E. J. (2019). Critical Soft Skills And The Stem Professional, For the degree of Doctor of Education, University of New England DUNE: DigitalUNE.
58. Landeta J. (2006). Current validity of the Delphi method in social sciences. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 73(5); 467-482.
59. Lavilles Jr, H L, Robles ACM. (2017). Teachers’ soft skills proϐiciency level and school performance of selected schools in Sultan Kudarat Division. Journal of Advances in Humanities and Social Sciences. 3(1), 10-28.
60. Lavy, I., & Yadin, A. (2013). Soft skills - an important key for employability in the "shift to a service driven economy" era. International Journal of e-Education, e-Business, eManagement and e-Learning, 3(5), 416.
61. Levant Y, Coulmont M, Sandu, R. (2016). Business simulation as an active learning activity for developing soft skills. Accounting Education. 25 (4), 368–395.
62. Levasseur R. E. (2013). People Skills: Developing Soft Skills—A Change Management Perspective. Interfaces. 43(6), 566–571.
63. Linstone, Harold A., Turoff, Murray. (1975). The Delphi Method: Techniques and Applications., Addison Wesley Publishing Company; First Edition Edition.
64. MacDermott, C., & Ortiz, L. (2017). “Beyond the business communication course: A historical perspective of the where, why, and how of soft skills development and job readiness for business graduates.” The IUP Journal of Soft Skills (XI: 2), 7-24.
65. Maguire, M., & Delahunt, B. (2017). Doing a Thematic Analysis: A Practical, Step-by-Step Guide for Learning and Teaching Scholars. AISHE-J, 9 (3), 3351-33514.
66. Majid S, Liming Z, Tong S, Raihana S. (2012). Importance of Soft Skills for Education and Career Success. International Journal for Cross-Disciplinary Subjects in Education (IJCDSE). 2 (2), 1036- 1042.
67. Makasiranondh, W., Maj, S.P. and Veal, D. (2011), “Student opinions on their development of nontechnical skills in IT education”, Modern Applied Science, 5 (2), 3-10
. 68. Matturro, G. (2013). Soft skills in software engineering: A study of its demand by software companies in Uruguay. May 2013 6th International Workshop on Cooperative and Human Aspects of Software Engineering (CHASE) (pp. 133–136).
69. Meeks G. (2017). Critical Soft Skills to Achieve Success in the Workplace. Doctoral Study Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Education. Walden University. College of Education.
70. Mishra K. (2014). Employability Skills That Recruiters Demand .IUP Journal of Soft Skills. 8 (3): 50-55.
71. Mitchell, G W. (2008). Essential soft skills for success in the ewenty- first century workforce as perceived by alabama business/marketing educators", A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of Auburn University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Education. Directed by Leane B. Skinner.
72. Moin R, Biswal S. (2012). SOFT SKILLS IN STATUS QUO. International Journal of Physical and Social Sciences. 2 (5), 212- 223.
73. NCVER (National Centre for Vocational Education Research). (2003). Defining generic skills: at a glance, NCVER, Adelaide.
74. Newell D. (2002). The smarter they are the harder they fall. Career Development Internat. 7(5):288–291.
75. Nonaka, I., & Johansson, J. K. (1985). Japanese management: What about the "hard" skills? The Academy of Management Review, 10(2), 181–191.
76. Nusrat M, Naz, K. (2018). Soft Skills for Sustainable Employment: Does it really Matter?. International Journal of Management and Economics Invention. 4 (7), 1835-1837
. 77. Pachauri D, Yadav A. (2014). Importance of Soft Skills in Teacher Education Programme. International Journal of Educational Research and Technology. 5 (1), 22-25.
78. Powell C. The Delphi technique: myths and realities. J Adv Nurs 2003 Feb; 41(4): 376-82.
79. Price A. (2000). Principles Human Resource Management. UK: Blackwell Business.
80. Quieng M-C, Lim P- P, Lucas R. (2015). 21st Century-based Soft Skills: Spotlight on Non-cognitive Skills in a Cognitive-laden Dentistry Program. European Journal of Contemporary Education. 11 (1), 72-81.
81. Ryan, G.W. and Russell Bernard, H. (2003) Techniques to Identify Themes. Field Methods, 15 (1), 85-109.
82. Rebele JE, St.Pierre EK. (2019). A commentary on learning objectives for accounting education programs: The importance of soft skills and technical knowledge. Journal of Accounting Education. 48(C), 71-79.
83. Richards T, Yellen R, Kappelman L, Guynes S. (1998). Information systems manager’s perceptions of IS job skills. J. Comput. Inform. Systems 38(3), 53–57.
84. Ritter, A., Small, E., Mortimer, J., and Doll, J. (2018). Designing management curriculum for workplace readiness: Developing student soft skills. Journal of Management Education, 42(1), 80-103.
85. Robert C, Bittel l. (2001). Training and Development. Handbook. New York: Mcgraw – Hill book Company.
86. Robles M. M. (2012). Executive perceptions of the top 10 soft skills needed in today’s workplace. Business Communication Quarterly. 75(4), 453-465.
87. Sabaghian, Z., Akbari, S.(2015). A comprehensive training in organizations (with adult education approach)., Tehran. Samt Publications.
88. Schulz B. (2008). The importance of soft skills: Education beyond academic knowledge. Journal of Language and Communication. 2(1), 146- 154.
89. Seetha N. (2014). Are Soft skills Important in the Workplace?– A Preliminary Investigation in Malaysia. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences. 4 (4), 44- 56.
90. Shakir R. (2009). Soft skills at the Malaysian institutes of higher learning. Asia Pacific Educ. 10 (3), 309–315.
91. Sharma G, Sharma P. (2010). Importance of Soft skills development in 21st century Curriculum. International Journal of Education and Allied Sciences July-Dec. 2 (2), 39-44.
92. Sigala, M. (2018). LEARNING AND DEVELOPMENT – TRENDS AND CHALLENGES., download fromhttps://www.academia.edu/40060556/Learning_and_Development_Trends_and_Challenges.
93. Snape, P. M. (2017). Enduring Learning: Integrating C21st soft skills through Technology Education. Design and Technology Education: An International Journal. 22 (3), 48-59.
94. Sodhi MS, Son B-G .(2008). ASP, the art and science of practice: Skills employers want from operations research graduates. Interfaces 38(2):140–146.
95. Sriruecha Ch, Buajan S. (2017). Leadership Soft Skills of the Director That Affects the Performance of the Subordinate at Sub district Health Promoting Hospitals. Social and Behavioral Sciences. 237, 1341– 1346.
96. Stewart, G. & Brown, K. (2011). Human Resource Management: linking strategy to practice. Danvers. John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
97. Stovall DC, Stovall PS. (2009). Professional accountants: Void of “soft skills”? Bus. Rev. 4(1):99–104.
98. Suhaili P, Ahmad E, Abidah- Ainah M- J. (2015). Soft Skills conrstruc for or arrchitecture graduate in accordance with industries requirement. International Journal of Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences. 1(3), 119-123.
99. Suryanti, H H S. (2019). Supeni S. A Problem Based Learning (PBL) Model in Developing Students' Soft Skills Aspect. International Journal of Higher Education. 8 (8), 62- 69.
100. Sutton, N. (2002). Why can’t we all just get along? Computing Canada, (28)16, 20.
101. Szilárd S, Benedeka A, Lucian- Ionel-C. (2018). Soft Skills Development Needs and Methods in Micro-Companies of ICT Sector. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences. (238), 94 – 103.
102. Tang K. N. (2018). The importance of soft skills acquisition by teachers in higher education institutions:, Kasetsart Journal of Social Sciences, 1-6.
103. Tang, Keow Ngang., Hashim, Nor Hashimah., Mohd Yunus, Hashimah., (2014), "Novice Teacher Perceptions of the Soft Skills Needed in Today's Workplace", Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 177 ( 2015 ) 284 – 288.
104. Taylor E. (2016). Investigating the Perception of Stakeholders on Soft Skills Development of Students: Evidence from South Africa. Interdisciplinary Journal of e-Skills and Lifelong Learning. 12, 1-18.
105. Taylor, J. O’Driscoll, P. (1998) “A new integrated framework for training needs analysis”. Human Resource Managment Journal. 8 (2).29-50.
106. Tseng H, Yi X, Yeh H-T. (2019). Learning-related soft skills among online business students in higher education: Grade level and managerial role differences in self-regulation, motivation and social skill. Computers in Human Behavior. 95, 179–186.
107. Weinberger, C. (2011). The Increasing Complementarity between Cognitive and Social Skills, Retrieved June 1, 2012, from http://www.econ.ucsb.edu/~weinberg/MathSocialWeinberger.pdf.
108. Verma Sh. (2013). Personality development & soft skills for class XI, first edition. New delhi. Goyal Brothers Prakashan.
109. Werner, Jon M & Desimone, Randy L. (2012). Human resource development, sixth edition, South-Western, Cengage Learning.
110. Villiers RD. (2010). The incorporation of soft skills into accountingcurricula: preparing accounting graduates for their unpredictable futures. Meditari Accountancy Research. 18 (2), 1-22.
111. Wilson-Ahlstrom A, Yohalem N, DuBois D, Ji P. (2011). From soft skills to hard data: measuring youth program outcomes. Washington, DC: The Forum for Youth Investment.
112. Windle PE. (2004). Delphi technique: assessing component needs. J Perianesth Nurs Feb; 19(1): 46-7.
113. Zhang, Aimao. (2012). "Peer Assessment of Soft Skills and Hard Skills", Journal of Information Technology Education: Research Volume 11, 155- 168.
1. Abbaszadegan SM, Torkzadeh J. (2009). surveys need training in organizations, Tehran, Press Release Joint Stock Company. 2. Abbaszadegan M, Torkzadeh G. (2000). [Need's assessment in organizations]. Tehran: Publishing Company.
3. Akdere, Mesut., Hickman, Louis., Kirchner, Michael., 2019., Developing Leadership Competencies for STEM Fields: The Case of Purdue Polytechnic Leadership Academy., Advances in Developing Human Resources, 21(3), 49-71.
4. Alam M, Gale A, Brown M, Khan AI .(2010) The importance of human skills in project management professional development. Internat. J. Managing Projects Bus. 3(3), 495-516.
5. Aminoroaya M, Yarmohammadiian MH, Ehsanpour S, Hassan zadeh A, Bahrami S. [Educational needs assessment of the staff managers in Isfahan University of Medical Sciences]. J Health Admin, 8(20):61- 7.
6. Andrew J, Higson, H. (2008). Graduate employability, ‘soft skills’ versus ‘hard’ business knowledge: A European study. Higher Education in Europe. 33(4). 411-422.
7. Armstrong Melser N. (2019). Teaching Soft Skills in a Hard World: Skills for Beginning Teachers, Rowman & Littlefield. M12.
8. Ahmed, Faheem., Fernando Capretz, Luiz., Bouktif, Salah., Campbell, Piers. (2013). Soft Skills and Software Development: A Reflection from Software Industry. International Journal of Information Processing and Management (IJIPM), 4 (3). 171-191.
9. Babić V, Slavković M. (2011). Soft and hard skills development: a current situation in serbian companies. Management, Knowledge ana Learning International Confronce. 407-411.
10. Bartel, J. (2018). Office Soft Skills. 3rd edition. https://wayzgoosepress.com.
11. Beardmore K W. (2019). Soft skills: old & new. University of Kentucky Uknowledge. Theses and Dissertations-Educational Policy Studies and Evaluation, https://uknowledge.uky.edu/epe_etds/65, A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Education, Director: Dr. Jane Jensen, College of Education, University of Kentucky.
12. Bergh AM, Van Staden CW, Joubert PM, Krüger C, Pickworth GE, Roos JL et al. (2006). Medical students perceptions of their development of ‘soft skills’ Part II : The development of ‘soft skills’ through ‘guiding and growing, Official journal of the South African Academy of Family Practice/Primary Care. 48 (8), 15.
13. Beretta R. A. (1996). critical review of the Delphi technique. Nurse Res, 3(4), 79–89.
14. Bhatnagar N, Bhatnagar M. (2012). Effective communication and soft skills, strategies for success. Dorling kindesley. Delhi, India. Blazquez M, Herrarte A, Llorente- Heras R. Competencies, occupational status, and earnings among European university graduates. Economics of Education Review. 2017; 62, 16-34.
15. BORGHANS, L., WEEL, B., WEINBERG, B. A. (2008). Interpersonal Styles and Labor Market Outcomes. Journal of Human Resources, 43 (4), 815-858.
16. Borner, K., Scrivner, O., Gallant, M., Ma, S., Liu, X., Chewning, K., Wu, L., & Evans, J. (2018). Skill discrepancies between research, education, and jobs reveal the critical need to supply soft skills for the data economy. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 115(50), 12630-12637.
17. Boyatzis, R E. (1982), The Competent Manager : A model for effective performance, Wiley, New York.
18. Brill R.T, Gilfoil D. M, Doll K. (2014). Exploring Predictability Of Instructor Ratings Using A Quantitative Tool For Evaluating Soft Skills Among MBA Students, American Journal Of Business Education- Third Quarter. 7 (3), 175- 181.
19. Braun, V. & Clarke, V. (2006). Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology, Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77-101.
20. Cherian, Jacob., Farouq, Sherine. (2013). Does Effective Leadership Style Drive Financial Performance of Banks? Analysis in the Context of UAE Banking Sector., International Journal of Economics and Finance; 5 (7), 105-114.
21. Cimatti B. (2016). Definition, development, assessment of soft skills and their role for the quality of organizations and enterprises. International Journal for Quality Research. 10(1), 97–130.
22. Cinque M. Lost in translation. (2016). Soft skills development in European countries. Tuning Journal for Higher Education. 3 (2): 389-427.
23. Clarke M. (2018). Rethinking graduate employability: The role of capital, individual attributes and context. Studies in Higher Education. 43(11), 1923-1937.
24. CPA Canada. (2012). The chartered professional accountant competency map. Understanding the competencies a candidate must demonstrate to become a CPA. Retrieved from http:// unification.cpacanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/CompetencyMap.pdf.
25. Crawford, Alleah., Weberb, Melvin R., Lee (Jay), JungHoon .(2020). "Using a grounded theory approach to understand the process ofteaching soft skills on the job so to apply it in the hospitalityclassroom", Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism Education 26,1002392, 2-7.
26. Dall’Amico, E., and Verona, S. (2015). Cross-Country Survey on Soft Skills Mostly Required by Companies to Medium/High Skilled Migrants: Methodological approach for a common framework of Soft Skills at work. Ceipiemonte S.c.p.a., for Valorize High Skills Migrant (VHSM) Project, No. 2014-1-IT02- KA204-003515. Torino, Italy.
27. Devedzic V, Tomic B, Jovanovic J, Kelly M, Milikic N, Dimitrijevic S et al. (2018). Metrics for students' soft skills. Applied Measurement in Education. 31(4), 283-296.
28. DewiyaniS M. J. (2015). Improving Students Soft Skills using Thinking Process Profile Based on Personality Types. International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education (IJERE). 4 (3), 118-129.
29. Dixon J, Belnap C, Albrecht C, Lee K (2010) The importance of soft skills. Corporate Finance Rev. 14(6):35–38.
30. Dubey RS, Tiwari V. (2020). Operationalisation of soft skill attributes and determining the existing gap in novice ICT professionals. International Journal of Information Management. 50, 375–386.
31. Fixsen, A., Ridge, D., 2019., Shades of Communitas: A Study of Soft Skills Programs, Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, 48(4), 510–537.
32. Graham HT, Bennett R. (2002), Human Resources management. London: Longman Group. 33. Ghahremani M. (2009). Organizational Learning Management Tehran, martyr Beheshti University Publications Center.
34. Ghorbanizadeh, V., Nangir, STH., (2014).,Practical guide to meta-analysis., Tehran., Sociologists Publications.
35. Gibert A, Tozer W. C, Westoby M. (2017). Teamwork, soft skills, and research training. Trends in ecology & evolution. 32(2), 81-84.
36. Grugulis, Irena., Vincent, Steven. (2009). “Whose skill is it anyway? ‘soft’ skills and polarization”, Work, employment and society, Volume 23(4), 597–615.
37. Hairi A. F B., Ahmad Toee, B. M N B, Razzaly, C.W B. (2011). Employers. perception on soft skills of graduates: a study of Intel Elite soft skill training, International Conference on Teaching & Learning in Higher Education (ICTLHE). https://www.researchgate.net/publication/279480523.
38. Hartmann, B. L., & Jahren, C. T. (2015). Leadership: Industry needs for entry-level engineering positions. Journal of STEM Education: Innovations and Research, 16(3), 13-19.
39. Hajati K, Rahmat Hidayat D, Aswad M. (2018). Development of Soft skill Training Models to Increase Personal and Social Competencies of Educators Prospective. International Journal of English Literature and Social Sciences (IJELS). 3 (6), 1253- 1257.
40. Haselberger D, Oberheumer P, Perez E, Cinque M, Capasso D. (2012). Mediating Soft Skills at Higher Education Institutions. Handbook of ModEs Project, Education and Culture DG Lifelong Learning Programme. European Union. Brussels.
41. Hillage, J., Regan, J., Dickson, J. and McLoughlin, K. (2002) Employers Skill Survey, 2002, Research Report 372. Nottingham: DfES.
42. Hillmer, G. (2007). Social and Soft Skills Training Concept in Engineering Education. International Conference on Engineering Education - ICEE 2007, September 3-7, 2007, Coimbra, Portugal.
43. Holloway, I. and Todres, L. (2003), The status of method: flexibility, consistency and coherence, Qualitative Research, 3, 345-357.
44. Holzer, H. J., Stoll, M. A., & Wissoker, D. (2004). Job performance and retention among welfare recipients. Social Service Review, 78(3), 343–369.
45. Ibrahim, Rosli., Boerhannoeddin, Ali., Kazeem Kayode, Bakare. (2017). The effect of soft skills and training methodology on employee performance, European Journal of Training and Development, 41 (4), 1-33.
46. Iyengar, R.V. (2017). People Matter: Networking and career development. The IUP Journal of Soft Skills, 11(1), 7-16.
47. Izadkhah, F., Ghaffari, M., Mohebbi, S., Gharlipour, Z., Ahmadi, Z., (2019)., Educational needs assessment of faculty members of Qom University of Medical Sciences; Journal of Qom University of Medical Sciences., 13 (9), 69-79.
48. Izadikhah, Z., Chris, J.J. and Loxton, N. (2010), “An integrative approach to personality: behavioural approach system, mastery approach orientation and environmental cues in the prediction of work performance”, Personality and Individual Differences, Vol. 48 No. 5, pp. 590-595.
49. Jain V.(2009). Importance of soft skills development in education. 2009, Retrieved July 8. 2014. from http://school of educators.com/2009/02/importance-of-soft-skills-development-in-education/.
50. Jolly S. S. (2012). Developing Soft Skills for Enhancing Employability of Engineering Graduates. International Journal of Engineeing and Management Research. 2(5), 54-56.
51. Kanokorn S, Pongtorn P, Sujanya S. (2014). Soft Skills Development to Enhance Teachers’ Competencies in Primary Schools". Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences. 112, 842 – 846.
52. Kechagias K. (2011). Teaching and assessing soft skills. 1st Second Chance School of Thessaloniki (Neapolis) Str. Strempenioti, 1st and 3rd Gymnasium 56760 Neapolis (Thessaloniki) available.
53. Keneley, M., & Jackling, B. (2011). The acquisition of generic skills of culturally-diverse student cohorts. Accounting Education, 20(6), 605–623.
54. Khaleghkhah, A., Najafi, H. (2018). Extraction of Soft Skills Components of Educational Managers by Exploratory Mixed Method (Design of a Measurement Tool), Quarterly Journal of New Approach in Educational Management, Year 9, 1 (3), 25-43.
55. Koka, Anjani Srikanth. (2016). A Critical Analysis of the Soft Skills Requirements of the IT industry and the Soft Skills Training Provided in Select Engineering Colleges of Andhra Prades, Birla Institute of Technology and Science, 225P, Birla Institute of Technology and Science.
56. Kovarik A, Warren G. (2020). Improved Soft Skills and University Club Involvement: Are They Connected?. Journal of Business. 5 (1), 01-06.
57. Kranz E. J. (2019). Critical Soft Skills And The Stem Professional, For the degree of Doctor of Education, University of New England DUNE: DigitalUNE.
58. Landeta J. (2006). Current validity of the Delphi method in social sciences. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 73(5); 467-482.
59. Lavilles Jr, H L, Robles ACM. (2017). Teachers’ soft skills proϐiciency level and school performance of selected schools in Sultan Kudarat Division. Journal of Advances in Humanities and Social Sciences. 3(1), 10-28.
60. Lavy, I., & Yadin, A. (2013). Soft skills - an important key for employability in the "shift to a service driven economy" era. International Journal of e-Education, e-Business, eManagement and e-Learning, 3(5), 416.
61. Levant Y, Coulmont M, Sandu, R. (2016). Business simulation as an active learning activity for developing soft skills. Accounting Education. 25 (4), 368–395.
62. Levasseur R. E. (2013). People Skills: Developing Soft Skills—A Change Management Perspective. Interfaces. 43(6), 566–571.
63. Linstone, Harold A., Turoff, Murray. (1975). The Delphi Method: Techniques and Applications., Addison Wesley Publishing Company; First Edition Edition.
64. MacDermott, C., & Ortiz, L. (2017). “Beyond the business communication course: A historical perspective of the where, why, and how of soft skills development and job readiness for business graduates.” The IUP Journal of Soft Skills (XI: 2), 7-24.
65. Maguire, M., & Delahunt, B. (2017). Doing a Thematic Analysis: A Practical, Step-by-Step Guide for Learning and Teaching Scholars. AISHE-J, 9 (3), 3351-33514.
66. Majid S, Liming Z, Tong S, Raihana S. (2012). Importance of Soft Skills for Education and Career Success. International Journal for Cross-Disciplinary Subjects in Education (IJCDSE). 2 (2), 1036- 1042.
67. Makasiranondh, W., Maj, S.P. and Veal, D. (2011), “Student opinions on their development of nontechnical skills in IT education”, Modern Applied Science, 5 (2), 3-10
. 68. Matturro, G. (2013). Soft skills in software engineering: A study of its demand by software companies in Uruguay. May 2013 6th International Workshop on Cooperative and Human Aspects of Software Engineering (CHASE) (pp. 133–136).
69. Meeks G. (2017). Critical Soft Skills to Achieve Success in the Workplace. Doctoral Study Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Education. Walden University. College of Education.
70. Mishra K. (2014). Employability Skills That Recruiters Demand .IUP Journal of Soft Skills. 8 (3): 50-55.
71. Mitchell, G W. (2008). Essential soft skills for success in the ewenty- first century workforce as perceived by alabama business/marketing educators", A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of Auburn University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Education. Directed by Leane B. Skinner.
72. Moin R, Biswal S. (2012). SOFT SKILLS IN STATUS QUO. International Journal of Physical and Social Sciences. 2 (5), 212- 223.
73. NCVER (National Centre for Vocational Education Research). (2003). Defining generic skills: at a glance, NCVER, Adelaide.
74. Newell D. (2002). The smarter they are the harder they fall. Career Development Internat. 7(5):288–291.
75. Nonaka, I., & Johansson, J. K. (1985). Japanese management: What about the "hard" skills? The Academy of Management Review, 10(2), 181–191.
76. Nusrat M, Naz, K. (2018). Soft Skills for Sustainable Employment: Does it really Matter?. International Journal of Management and Economics Invention. 4 (7), 1835-1837
. 77. Pachauri D, Yadav A. (2014). Importance of Soft Skills in Teacher Education Programme. International Journal of Educational Research and Technology. 5 (1), 22-25.
78. Powell C. The Delphi technique: myths and realities. J Adv Nurs 2003 Feb; 41(4): 376-82.
79. Price A. (2000). Principles Human Resource Management. UK: Blackwell Business.
80. Quieng M-C, Lim P- P, Lucas R. (2015). 21st Century-based Soft Skills: Spotlight on Non-cognitive Skills in a Cognitive-laden Dentistry Program. European Journal of Contemporary Education. 11 (1), 72-81.
81. Ryan, G.W. and Russell Bernard, H. (2003) Techniques to Identify Themes. Field Methods, 15 (1), 85-109.
82. Rebele JE, St.Pierre EK. (2019). A commentary on learning objectives for accounting education programs: The importance of soft skills and technical knowledge. Journal of Accounting Education. 48(C), 71-79.
83. Richards T, Yellen R, Kappelman L, Guynes S. (1998). Information systems manager’s perceptions of IS job skills. J. Comput. Inform. Systems 38(3), 53–57.
84. Ritter, A., Small, E., Mortimer, J., and Doll, J. (2018). Designing management curriculum for workplace readiness: Developing student soft skills. Journal of Management Education, 42(1), 80-103.
85. Robert C, Bittel l. (2001). Training and Development. Handbook. New York: Mcgraw – Hill book Company.
86. Robles M. M. (2012). Executive perceptions of the top 10 soft skills needed in today’s workplace. Business Communication Quarterly. 75(4), 453-465.
87. Sabaghian, Z., Akbari, S.(2015). A comprehensive training in organizations (with adult education approach)., Tehran. Samt Publications.
88. Schulz B. (2008). The importance of soft skills: Education beyond academic knowledge. Journal of Language and Communication. 2(1), 146- 154.
89. Seetha N. (2014). Are Soft skills Important in the Workplace?– A Preliminary Investigation in Malaysia. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences. 4 (4), 44- 56.
90. Shakir R. (2009). Soft skills at the Malaysian institutes of higher learning. Asia Pacific Educ. 10 (3), 309–315.
91. Sharma G, Sharma P. (2010). Importance of Soft skills development in 21st century Curriculum. International Journal of Education and Allied Sciences July-Dec. 2 (2), 39-44.
92. Sigala, M. (2018). LEARNING AND DEVELOPMENT – TRENDS AND CHALLENGES., download fromhttps://www.academia.edu/40060556/Learning_and_Development_Trends_and_Challenges.
93. Snape, P. M. (2017). Enduring Learning: Integrating C21st soft skills through Technology Education. Design and Technology Education: An International Journal. 22 (3), 48-59.
94. Sodhi MS, Son B-G .(2008). ASP, the art and science of practice: Skills employers want from operations research graduates. Interfaces 38(2):140–146.
95. Sriruecha Ch, Buajan S. (2017). Leadership Soft Skills of the Director That Affects the Performance of the Subordinate at Sub district Health Promoting Hospitals. Social and Behavioral Sciences. 237, 1341– 1346.
96. Stewart, G. & Brown, K. (2011). Human Resource Management: linking strategy to practice. Danvers. John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
97. Stovall DC, Stovall PS. (2009). Professional accountants: Void of “soft skills”? Bus. Rev. 4(1):99–104.
98. Suhaili P, Ahmad E, Abidah- Ainah M- J. (2015). Soft Skills conrstruc for or arrchitecture graduate in accordance with industries requirement. International Journal of Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences. 1(3), 119-123.
99. Suryanti, H H S. (2019). Supeni S. A Problem Based Learning (PBL) Model in Developing Students' Soft Skills Aspect. International Journal of Higher Education. 8 (8), 62- 69.
100. Sutton, N. (2002). Why can’t we all just get along? Computing Canada, (28)16, 20.
101. Szilárd S, Benedeka A, Lucian- Ionel-C. (2018). Soft Skills Development Needs and Methods in Micro-Companies of ICT Sector. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences. (238), 94 – 103.
102. Tang K. N. (2018). The importance of soft skills acquisition by teachers in higher education institutions:, Kasetsart Journal of Social Sciences, 1-6.
103. Tang, Keow Ngang., Hashim, Nor Hashimah., Mohd Yunus, Hashimah., (2014), "Novice Teacher Perceptions of the Soft Skills Needed in Today's Workplace", Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 177 ( 2015 ) 284 – 288.
104. Taylor E. (2016). Investigating the Perception of Stakeholders on Soft Skills Development of Students: Evidence from South Africa. Interdisciplinary Journal of e-Skills and Lifelong Learning. 12, 1-18.
105. Taylor, J. O’Driscoll, P. (1998) “A new integrated framework for training needs analysis”. Human Resource Managment Journal. 8 (2).29-50.
106. Tseng H, Yi X, Yeh H-T. (2019). Learning-related soft skills among online business students in higher education: Grade level and managerial role differences in self-regulation, motivation and social skill. Computers in Human Behavior. 95, 179–186.
107. Weinberger, C. (2011). The Increasing Complementarity between Cognitive and Social Skills, Retrieved June 1, 2012, from http://www.econ.ucsb.edu/~weinberg/MathSocialWeinberger.pdf.
108. Verma Sh. (2013). Personality development & soft skills for class XI, first edition. New delhi. Goyal Brothers Prakashan.
109. Werner, Jon M & Desimone, Randy L. (2012). Human resource development, sixth edition, South-Western, Cengage Learning.
110. Villiers RD. (2010). The incorporation of soft skills into accountingcurricula: preparing accounting graduates for their unpredictable futures. Meditari Accountancy Research. 18 (2), 1-22.
111. Wilson-Ahlstrom A, Yohalem N, DuBois D, Ji P. (2011). From soft skills to hard data: measuring youth program outcomes. Washington, DC: The Forum for Youth Investment.
112. Windle PE. (2004). Delphi technique: assessing component needs. J Perianesth Nurs Feb; 19(1): 46-7.
113. Zhang, Aimao. (2012). "Peer Assessment of Soft Skills and Hard Skills", Journal of Information Technology Education: Research Volume 11, 155- 168.
