راست افراطی و آفرینش جغرافیای تخیلی اسطورهای اروپا؛ رویکرد چرخش تصاویر میچل
محورهای موضوعی : پژوهش سیاست نظریفریده محمدعلی پور 1 , محمد نصیرزاده 2
1 - استادیار گروه روابط بینالملل، دانشکده حقوق و علوم سیاسی دانشگاه خوارزمی
2 - دانشآموخته کارشناسی¬ارشد روابط بینالملل، دانشکده حقوق و علوم سیاسی دانشگاه خوارزمی
کلید واژه: راست افراطی, جغرافیای تخیلی, هویت, رویکرد چرخش تصاویر میچل و اروپای اسطورهای. ,
چکیده مقاله :
راست افراطی در کشورهای اروپایی با اتکا به یک جغرافیای تخیلی، به تعریف خود اسطورهای دست یازیده و در این فرایند از کسانی که برحسب آرمانهای ایشان فداکاری کردهاند، بهره برده است. پژوهش حاضر در راستای پاسخ به این پرسش که چگونه راست افراطی بر آفرینش جغرافیای تخیلی اسطورهای در اروپا تأثیر گذاشتهاند، این فرضیه را با استفاده از نظریۀ چرخش تصویر میچل بررسی کرده است که راست افراطی از طریق بازشناسی انگاره و تصویر بر آفرینش جغرافیای تخیلی اسطورهای در اروپا تأثیر گذاشته است. نتایج حاصل از پژوهش نشان میدهد که گروههای راست افراطی همانند سربازان او دین و نئونازیها با بازشناسی تصاویر فداکاری در فرهنگ وایکینگها، گفتمان نازیسم و تصاویر برخی از معاصران، به این تصاویر جایگاه آیینی بخشیده و از تصور آنها بهعنوان عامل هویت هویتبخش و اعتباربخش استفاده کرده است. راست افراطی با اتکا به مسابقه ورزشی، لباس و موسیقی به بازشناسی تصور این تصاویر پرداخته است.
The Radical Right in European countries has achieved the definition of a mythical self by relying on an imaginary geography and in this process has benefited from those who have sacrificed for their ideals. The research question concerns how radical right groups have affected the creation of imaginary-mythicalgeography in Europe. The hypothesis which is tested based on Mitchell’s pictorial turn theory is that radical right groups have affected Europe through picture and image recognition to create imaginary-mythical geography and have resulted in the strengthening of their social identity. The results of the study show that the radical right has recognized those who have sacrificed by holding musical and athletic events and in this way have strengthened social identity in imaginary-mythical geography.
Aljazeera (2021) Afghan Buddha in virtual return, 20 years after Taliban destroyed: https: //www. aljazeera. com/news/2021/3/10/afghan-buddha-in-virtual-return-20-years-after-taliban-destroyed.
Anti-Defamation League (2019) Hardcore White Supremacists Elevate Dylann Roof to Cult Hero Status: https: //www. adl. org/blog/hardcore-white-supremacists-elevate-dylann-roof-to-cult-hero-status.
Armeemuseum (2021) Das Ehrenzeichen vom 9. November 1923, Blutorden: http: //www. armeemuseum. de/de/aktuell/objekt-des-monats/1443-objekt-blutorden. html.
BBC (2011) Top Nazi Rudolf Hess exhumed from 'pilgrimage' grave: https: //www. bbc. com/news/world-europe-14232768.
Ben Am, Ari & Weimann, Gabriel (2020) "Fabricated Martyrs: The Warrior-Saint Icons of Far-Right Terrorism", PERSPECTIVES ON TERRORISM, Volume 14, Issue 5: 130-147.
Bennhold, Katrin (2019) Donation from New Zealand Attack Suspect Puts Spotlight on Europe’s Far Right", Nytimes: https: //www. nytimes. com/2019/03/27/world/europe/new-zealand-attack-europe-far-right. html.
Berger, J (2016) The Turner Legacy: The storied origins and enduring impact of White Nationalism’s Deadly Bible. The International Centre for Counter-Terrorism: https: //icct. nl/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/ICCT-Berger-The-TurnerLegacy-September2016-2. pdf.
Bianchi, Enzo (2008) Witness and martyrdom in the Bible: https: //www. monasterodibose. it/en/hospitality/conferences/on-spirituality/887-2008-cloud-of-witnesses/3911-witness-and-martyrdom-in-the-bible.
Biebuyck,William (2010) “European Imaginaries and the Intelligibility of Integration. ” Journal of Contemporary European Studies, Volume18, Issue 2: 161–180.
Boler, Megan, & Elizabeth, Davis (2018) "The Affective Politics of the ‘Post-Truth’ Era: Feeling Rules and Networked Subjectivity, Emotion, Space and Society, Volume 27: 75–85.
Breivik, Anders (2011) 2083 – a European Declaration of Independence. Washingtonpost: https: //www. washingtonpost. com/r/2010-2019/ WashingtonPost/2011/07/24/National-Politics/Graphics/2083+-+A+European+Declaration+of+Independence. pdf.
Buesnel, Ryan (2020) "National Socialist Black Metal: a case study in the longevity of far-right ideologies in heavy metal subcultures", Patterns of Prejudice, Volume 54, Issue 4: 1-16.
Casquete, Jesús (2009) Martyr construction and the politics of death in National Socialism. Totalitarian Movements and Political Religions, Volume 10, Issue 3-4, 265-283.
Charvát, Jan (2019) The Role and Importance of White Power Music in Shaping the Far Right in the Czech Republic, In Popular music in Communist and Post-Communist Europe (pp. 241-251), Peter Lang.
Claus, Robert (2018) Der, Kampf der Nibelungen‘ dient der Vernetzung und Finanzierung der Neonazi-Szene: https: //translate. google. com/?hl=fa&sl =auto&tl=fa&text=Der%20%2CKampf%20der%20Nibelungen%E2%80%98%20dient%20der%20Vernetzung%20und%20Finanzierung%20der%20Neonazi-Szene%E2%80%9C&op=translate.
---------------- (2020) Wie Europas extreme Rechte für den Umsturz trainiert: https: //www. deutschlandfunkkultur. de/robert-claus-ihr-kampf-wie-europas-extreme-rechte-fuer-den-100. html.
Colborne, Michael (2020) Dispatches from Asgardsrei: Ukraine’s Annual Neo-Nazi Music Festival: https: //www. bellingcat. com/news/2020/01/02/ dispatches-from-asgardsrei-ukraines-annual-neo-nazi-music-festival.
Counter extremism (2019) English Defence League (EDL): https: //www. counterextremism. com/supremacy/english-defence-league-edl.
Dodds, Klaus (2001) "Political Geography III: Critical Geopolitics after Ten Years" Progress in Human Geography, Vol 25, Issue 3: 469–484.
Earnest, John (2019) An open letter: https: //bcsh. bard. edu/files/2019/06/Earnest-Manifesto-042719. pdf.
Ebner, Julia (2017) The Rage The Vicious Circle of Islamist and Far-Right Extremism, London, B. Tauris &Co: London.
Elgenius, GABRIELLA. & Rydgren, JENS (2017) "The Sweden democrats and the ethno-nationalist rhetoric of decay and betrayal", Sociologisk Forskning, Vol. 54, No. 4, 353–358.
Engel, Richard & Denne, Luke (2020) Neo-Nazis from U. S. and Europe build far-right links at concerts in Germany: https: //www. nbcnews. com/news/us-news/neo-nazis-u-s-europe-build-far-right-links-concerts-n1165266.
Engelbrecht, Cora (2022) Far-right militias in Europe plan to confront Russian forces, a research group says: https: //www. nytimes. com/2022/02/25/ world/europe/militias-russia-ukraine. html.
Erfurt, Kriminalität (2018) Auftritte rechtsextremer Bands in Themar beschäftigen Justiz: https: //www. sueddeutsche. de/panorama/kriminalitaet-erfurt-auftritte-rechtsextremer-bands-in-themar-beschaeftigen-justiz-dpa. urn-newsml-dpa-com-20090101-180406-99-778525.
Esposito, Fernando (2020) Era Fascista: Italian Fascism’s New Beginning and Its Roman Past Future, Palgrave Macmillan.
Europol (2019) Advisory Network on Terrorism and Propaganda Workshop: “Defining the global right-wing extremist movement: https: //www. europol. europa. eu/media-press/newsroom/news/advisory-network-terrorism-and-propaganda-workshop-%e2%80%9cdefining-global-right-wing-extremist-movement%e2%80%9d.
Feder, Avraham (2009) Idolatry by Any Other Name. The Jerusalem Post, https: //www. jpost. com/opinion/op-ed-contributors/idolatry-by-any-other-name.
Galdrtanz (2013) TEIWAZ: http: //galdrtanz-runedance. blogspot. com/2013/03/ teiwaz. html.
García, Louie (2020) Far-Right Revisionism and the End of History, New York, Routledge.
Gardell, Mattias (2003) Gods of the blood: The pagan revival and white separatism, Durham, Duke University Press.
Generation (2017) Handbuch Für Medienguerillas: Teil I. Shitposting 1×1: https: //www. hogesatzbau. de/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/ HANDBUCH-F%c3%9cR-MEDIENGUERILLAS. pdf.
Georges, Dumézil (1988) Mitra-Varuna: An Essay on Two Indo-European Representations of Sovereignty, Translated by Derek Coltman, Zone Books.
Goeschel, Goeschel (2006) "Suicide at the End of the Third Reich", Journal of Contemporary History, Vol 41, Issue 1: 153–173.
Gould, Charles (2010) Mythical Monsters, New York, Cosimo Classics.
Graham, Emily (2014) "Breivik is my Hero: the Dystopian World of Extreme Right Youth on the Internet", Australian Journal of Politics & History, Vol 60, Issue 3, 416–430.
Guardian (2002) Pim the martyr unites a city in grief: https: //www. theguardian. com/world/2002/may/08/thefarright. politics3.
---------- (2020) Praise for alleged Kenosha shooter proliferates on Facebook despite supposed ban: https: //www. theguardian. com/technology /2020/aug/27/facebook-kenosha-shooter-support-ban.
Hameleers, Michael& Schmuck, Desirée (2017) "It’s us against them: A comparative experiment on the effects of populist messages communicated via social media",Information, Communication & Society, Vol 20, Issue 9, 1425–1444.
Harley, Nicky (2021) Music festivals make millions in revenue for far-right extremists: https: //www. thenationalnews. com/world/music-festivals-make-millions-in-revenue-for-far-right-extremists-1. 1142369.
Higgins, Mary & Eicher, Joanne (1992) "Dress and Identity", Clothing and Textile Research Journal, Vol 10, Issue 4: 1-8.
Historyextra (2021) Valhalla: fighting and feasting in the Viking warrior afterlife: https: //www. historyextra. com/period/viking/valhalla-facts-viking-afterlife-norse-mythology-asgard.
Hock, Von (2020) Kampf der Nibelungen: Bundeswehrangehörige besuchten rechtsextremes Kampfsportevent: https: //www. monika-lazar. de/politik/ sport/sport-detailansicht/kampf-der-nibelungen-bundeswehrangehoerige-besuchten-rechtsextremes-kampfsportevent.
Hodson, Dermot (2021a) "The visual politics and policy of Donald Trump" Policy Studies, Volume 42, Issue 5-6: 1–19.
----------------- (2021b) "The Politics of Documentary Photography: Three Theoretical Perspectives" Government and Opposition, Volume56, Issue 1: 20–38.
Hodun, Milosz (2020) From Poland with Love, February, https: //www. freiheit. org/central-europe-and-baltic-states/poland-love-february.
Hoffman, Bruce, & Mccopmick, Gordon (2004)"Terrorism, Signaling, and Suicide Attack", Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, Volume 27, Issue 4, 243–281.
Hopton, J (2003) The State and Military Masculinity” In Military Masculinities: Identity and the State, edited by Paul R. Higate, (pp111–124). Westport, CT: Praeger.
Hume, Tim (2021) The Swastika Is Going To Be Banned in Parts of Australia, https: //www. vice. com/en/article/v7ekgm/the-swastika-is-going-to-be-banned-in-parts-of-australia.
Hume, Tim. , Bennett, Tom & Langston, Henry (2021) Neo-Nazi Music Festivals Are Funding Violent Extremism in Europe: https: //www. vice. com/en/article/wx533x/neo-nazi-music-festivals-are-funding-violent-extremism-in-europe.
Independent (2018) Berlin protests: Far-right and anti-Nazi activists clash on anniversary of Rudolf Hess death: https: //www. independent. co. uk/ news/world/europe/berlin-nazi-march-anti-facist-police-injured-rudolf-hess-a8497661. html.
Johns, Nick and Clarke, V. (2001) "Mythological analysis of boating touris" Annals of Tourism Research, 28: 334-359.
Kaarina Nikunen, Hokka, Jenni & Nelimarkka, matti (2020) Affective Practice of Soldiering: How Sharing Images Is Used to Spread Extremist and Racist Ethos on Soldiers of Odin Facebook Sit, Television & New Media,Vol 22, Issue 2: 166–185.
Kahn-Harris, Keith (2007) Extreme Metal: Music and Culture on the Edge, Oxford: Berg.
Kelly, Annie (2017) The Alt-right: Reactionary Rehabilitation for White Masculinity, Soundings, 66, 68–78.
Kinetz, Erika (2021) Neo-Nazis are still on Facebook. And they’re making money: detroitnews: https: //www. detroitnews. com/story/news/nation/2021/09/25/neo-nazis-facebook-money-right-wing-extremists/118948274.
Knight, Ben (2022) Germany's far-right split by Russia-Ukraine war, https: //www. dw. com/en/germanys-far-right-split-by-russia-ukraine-war/a-61283065.
Koehler, Daniel (2020) "Dying for the cause? The logic and function of ideologically motivated suicide, martyrdom, and self-sacrifice within the contemporary extreme right", Behavioral Sciences of Terrorism and Political Aggression: 1-22.
Kølvraa,Christoffer (2019) "Embodying ‘the Nordic race’: imaginaries of Viking heritage in the online communications of the Nordic Resistance Movement", Patterns of Prejudice, Vol 53, Issue 3: 270-284.
Kolvraa, Christoffer & Forchtner,Bernhard (2019) "Cultural Imaginaries of the Extreme Right", An Introduction. Patterns Prejud, Vol 53, Issue, 3: 227–235.
Kriesi, Hanspeter (2016) "The Politicization of European Integration,” JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, Vol 54, Issue 1: 32–47.
Langenbacher, Nora & Britta Schellenberg (2011) IS EUROPE ON THE “RIGHT” PATH? Behalf of the Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung Forum Berlin.
Light, Duncan (2008) Imaginative Geographies, Dracula and the Transylvania ‘Place Myth: http: //www. gabrielsimion. net/humangeographies. org. ro/articles/22/Light. pdf.
Madfis, Eric & Vysotsky, Stanislav (2020) "Exploring Subcultural Trajectories: Racist Skinhead Disengagement, Desistance, and Countercultural Value Persistence", Sociological Focus, Vol 53, Issue 3, 221-235.
Mammone, Andrea (2022) The Russia-Ukraine war put Europe’s far right on the back foot: https: //www. aljazeera. com/opinions/2022/3/20/the-ukraine-russia-war-put-europes-far-right-on-the-back-foot.
McGillen, Michael (2020) "Orientation in pictures: multistable spaces in Kafka and Beckett", Word & Image, Vol 36, Issue 3, 225–236.
Melzer, Ralf (2014) Right-Wingin Europe Extremism: Country Analyses, Counter-Strategies and Labor-Market Oriented Exit Strategies,COUNTRY ANALYSES SWEDEN: https: //library. fes. de/pdf-files/dialog/10031. pdf.
Memento (2020) Vademecum-Lo spirito dei volontari: https: //www. associazione-memento. org/chisiamo.
Miller-Idriss, Cynthia (2017) "Soldier, sailor, rebel, rule-breaker: masculinity and the body in the German far right", Gender and Education, Vol 29, Issue 2, 199-215.
---------------------------- (2018) The extreme gone mainstream: Commercialization and far right youth culture in Germany, Princeton Princeton University Press.
---------------------------- (2019) Selling extremism: Nationalist streetwear and the rise of the far right, CNN: https: //edition. cnn. com/style/article/right-wing-fashion-streetwear/index. html.
Mitchell,Thomas (1994) The Reconfigured Eye: Visual Truth in the Post-Photographic Era, Cambridge, MA, MIT Press.
---------------------------- (2005) What Do Pictures Want? The Lives and Loves of Images, Chicago, University of Chicago Press.
--------------------- (2011) Cloning Terror: The War of Images, 9/11 to the Present. Chicago, IL, University of Chicago Press.
-------------------- (2015) Image Science: Iconology, Visual Culture, and Media Aesthetics, Chicago, IL, University of Chicago Press.
------------------- (2017) American Psychosis: Trumpism and the Nightmare of History. ” Los Angeles Time: https: //lareviewofbooks. org/article/american-psychosis-trumpism-and-the-nightmare-of-history.
Mmaviking (2020) About MMA Viking: https: //www. mmaviking. com/about-mma-viking.
Motståndsrörelsen (2020) Vad är nationalsocialism? https: //xn--motstndsrrelsen-llb70a. se/vad-ar-nationalsocialism.
---------------------- (2021) Nordendagarna 2021: https: //xn--motstndsrrelsen-llb70a. se/2021/08/15/nordendagarna-2021.
NBC (2020) Kyle Rittenhouse, charged with killing 2 Kenosha protesters, has bond set at $2M: https: //www. nbcnews. com/news/us-news/kyle-rittenhouse-charged-killing-2-kenosha-protesters-has-bond-set-n1245953.
Nelis, Jan (2014) "Back to the Future: Italian Fascist Representations of the Roman Past", Fascism: Journal of Comparative Fascist Studies,)3 ( 1–19.
Nikunen, K (2019) Emotions, Affect and the Media,In Media & Society, edited,Curran James and Hesmondhalgh, David, (ed) (pp323–340). London: Bloomsbury.
Nordic Resistance Movement (2020) Remembering Daniel Wretström 20 years on: https: //nordicresistancemovement. org/remembering-daniel-wretstrom-20-years-on/?__cf_chl_managed_tk__=pmd_Rd0chMeqoF_5mQoBVJpnumPGLTnYYMxRbw9hUrRKMxY-1634310727-0-gqNtZGzNAvujcnBszQoR.
Nypost (2021a) Sinéad O’Connor explains why she ripped up photo of the pope on ‘SNL’: https: //nypost. com/2021/06/01/sinead-oconnor-on-why-she-ripped-up-photo-of-pope-on-snl.
--------- (2021b) Neo-Nazis are still on Facebook. And they’re making money: https: //nypost. com/2021/09/27/neo-nazis-are-still-on-facebook-and-theyre-making-money.
Pasieka, Agnieszka (2019)"Anthropology of the far right, or: What if we like the unlikeable others?” Anthropology Today, Volume35, Issue1: 3–6.
Pdfslide (2020) A Practical Guide to The Strategy and Tactics of Revolution: https: //pdfslide. net/documents/a-practical-guide-to-the-strategy-and-tactics-of-revolution. html.
Pierce, W (1978) The Turner diaries. Retrieved December 24, 2019, from https: //archive. org/details/ TurnerDiaries.
Pollard (2016) Skinhead culture: the ideologies, mythologies, religions and conspiracy theories of racist skinheads, Patterns of Prejudice: 398–419.
Ravndal, Jacob (2019) Transnational Militancy in the Making: A Primer on the Nordic Resistance Movement and Generation Identity, Oslo, Center for Research on Extremism.
Richards, Imogen (2019) "A Philosophical and Historical Analysis of “Generation Identity”: Fascism, Online Media, and the European New Right", Terrorism and Political Violence,1–20.
Rogers (2020) Has Given The Right Hundreds Of New Martyrs: https: //fivethirtyeight. com/features/jan-6-has-given-the-right-hundreds-of-new-martyrs/.
Rose, ARNO (1977) Radikaler Luftkampf: Die Geschichte deutscher Rammjäger, Motorbuch, Verlag.
Rudnicki, Szymon (1985) Obóz Narodowo-Radykalny. Geneza i działalność. Warszawa, Czytelnik: http: //otworzksiazke. pl/images/ksiazki/oboz_narodowo_radykalny/oboz_narodowo_radykalny. pdf. Shekhovtsov,Anton & Paul, Jackson (2012) White Power Music: Scenes of Extreme- Right Cultural ResistanceIlford, Searchlight Magazine/ Northampton, Radicalism and New Media Group.
Siemens, Daniel (2013) The Making of a Nazi Hero: The Murder and Myth of Horst Wessel, trans. David Burnett, I. B, London, Tauris.
Ssociazione (2021) COMO, 28 GIUGNO 1921-2021: https: //www. associazione-memento. org/2021/07/ricordato-il-centenario-del-martirio-di-jolando-tamberi.
Tarrant, Brenton (2019) The Great Replacement. https: //brill. com /downloadpdf/journals/ehcs/5/1/article-p25_4. xml.
Tetzner, Noah (2020) Valhalla: How Viking Belief in a Glorious Afterlife Empowered Warriors: https: //www. history. com/news/viking-valhalla-valkyrie-afterlife.
The times (2021)What the neo Nazi fanatic did next: switched to Islam: https: //www. thetimes. co. uk/article/what-the-neo-nazi-fanatic-did-next-switched-to-islam-qv3ph5k0jv8.
Thorleifsson, Cathrine (2019) “The Swedish dystopia: violent imaginaries of the radical right”, Patterns of Prejudice, 53: 5, 515-533, DOI: 10. 1080/0031322X. 2019. 1656888.
Thorsteinar (2021) Home: https: //www. thorsteinar. de/en/.
Thorsteinar katalog (2021) Thor steinar kataloqe: https: //www. thorsteinar-katalog. de.
Tilles, Daniel (2021) Far-right group can be called “fascist”, rules Poland’s Supreme Court: https: //notesfrompoland. com/2021/02/28/far-right-group-can-be-called-fascists-rules-polands-supreme-court.
Time. (1993) GERMANY: Schlageter Day: http: //content. time. com/time /subscriber/article/0,33009,745625,00. html.
Tolonen, Anna (2011) The Reception of the Maccabean Martyrs: The Religious Roots of Europe Faculty of Theology, University of Helsinki: https: //helda. helsinki. fi/bitstream/handle/10138/29477/therecep. pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y.
Traces of war (2021) Temples of Honour Königsplatz: https: //www. tracesofwar. com/sights/20144/Temples-of-Honour-K%C3%B6nigsplatz. htm.
Van Gelder, Lawrence (1975) Otto Skorzeny, Nazi Commando, Dead; Rescued Mussolini from Italian Peak, The New York Times: https: //www. nytimes. com/1975/07/08/archives/otto-skorzeny-nazi-commando-dead-rescued-mussolini-from-italian. html.
Watkins, Josh (2015) "Spatial imaginaries research in geography: Synergies, tensions, and new directions. Geography Compass", Volume 9, Issue 9: 508–522.
Whelan, Brian (2013) Ian Stuart Donaldson and a legacy of hate: https: //www. channel4. com/news/ian-stuart-donaldson-a-legacy-of-hate.
Zhao, Steven (2020) "Examining and problematizing the journalistic discourses of radical rightism", Educational Philosophy and Theory: 1-11.